Evaluate HyperTwist Phase 0R packet 0R-A

2026-05-12 21:03:40 +02:00 · 2026-05-12 21:03:40 +02:00 · af1226ff30
commit af1226ff30
parent eb00ea6586
4 changed files with 330 additions and 3 deletions
--- a/docs/HYPERTWIST_CANONICAL_RESTART_RECONCILIATION_2026-05-12.md
+++ b/docs/HYPERTWIST_CANONICAL_RESTART_RECONCILIATION_2026-05-12.md
@ -393,10 +393,25 @@ After this reconciliation:
 - no canonical doc should use `implemented`, `full`, or `already live` for a repo unless current first-party evidence supports it
 - no clean-room doc should describe `onionhoney/roux-trainers` as the next pending restrictive implementation lane without also saying it is already the landed restrictive clean-room precedent

+## Current packet status
+
+`Packet 0R-A` is now closed as an evaluation packet.
+
+See:
+
+- `docs/HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md`
+
+Result:
+
+- all seven `0R-A` repos remain retained
+- none of the seven are currently proven live in checked Unreal surfaces
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr` is the earliest straight permissive subsystem implementation candidate after `Phase 2R`
+- the other six remain retained anchors or later specialized donors
+
 ## Practical next move

 The next bounded move is:

-1. open `Phase 0R`
-2. start `Packet 0R-A`
-3. ratify the retained-set decision for the architecture anchors before widening any later roadmap lane
+1. keep `Phase 3R+` widening frozen
+2. open `Packet 0R-B`
+3. continue the retained permissive evaluation backlog until the broader `Phase 0R` set is actually closed
--- a/docs/HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md
+++ b/docs/HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md
@ -0,0 +1,261 @@
+# HyperTwist Phase 0R Packet 0R-A Evaluation
+
+Created on `2026-05-12`
+
+## Purpose
+
+This document closes the first `Phase 0R` evaluation packet for the seven architecture-anchor permissive repos that were explicitly scheduled as `Packet 0R-A` in the restart reconciliation.
+
+It answers, for each repo:
+
+- whether it survives the `Phase 0R` retained-set reset
+- whether it is already live in checked Unreal surfaces
+- what implementation lane it should take if retained
+- when it should be scheduled in the restart sequence
+
+## Packet scope
+
+This packet evaluates:
+
+- `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`
+- `kkoomen/qbr`
+- `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr`
+- `roice3/MagicTile`
+- `roice3/Magic120Cell`
+- `roice3/MagicCube5D`
+
+These are the exact repos named as `Packet 0R-A` in [HYPERTWIST_CANONICAL_RESTART_RECONCILIATION_2026-05-12.md](C:/HyperTwist/docs/HYPERTWIST_CANONICAL_RESTART_RECONCILIATION_2026-05-12.md:1).
+
+## Inputs used
+
+This packet was evaluated against:
+
+- the current reset board in [HYPERTWIST_REPO_STATE_BOARD_2026-05-11.md](C:/HyperTwist/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_STATE_BOARD_2026-05-11.md:1)
+- the current reset schedule in [HYPERTWIST_REPO_EVALUATION_RESET_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_SCHEDULE_2026-05-11.md](C:/HyperTwist/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_EVALUATION_RESET_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_SCHEDULE_2026-05-11.md:1)
+- the current root tracker in [REPO_LICENSE_TRACKING.md](C:/HyperTwist/docs/REPO_LICENSE_TRACKING.md:1)
+- the seven source-backed dossier files:
+  - [18-hactarce-hyperspeedcube-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/18-hactarce-hyperspeedcube-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [19-kkoomen-qbr-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/19-kkoomen-qbr-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [20-vivaansinghvi07-rubix-cube-solver-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/20-vivaansinghvi07-rubix-cube-solver-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [37-aarav2709-kubetimr-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/37-aarav2709-kubetimr-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [15-roice3-magictile-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/15-roice3-magictile-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [16-roice3-magic120cell-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/16-roice3-magic120cell-upstream-dossier.md>)
+  - [17-roice3-magiccube5d-upstream-dossier.md](</C:/visual_studio_solutions/multi_project/GPT 5.4 HyperTwist parse/17-roice3-magiccube5d-upstream-dossier.md>)
+
+## Live-evidence method
+
+Current live-evidence checks for this packet were run against:
+
+- `C:\HyperTwist\UnrealHyperTwist\Source`
+- `C:\HyperTwist\UnrealHyperTwist\Content\HyperTwistTraining\MaterializedCatalog`
+
+Check method:
+
+- exact repo-name or common-name string search in checked Unreal source and materialized catalog surfaces
+
+Result:
+
+- no exact live-surface match was found for any of the seven `Packet 0R-A` repos
+
+This means:
+
+- none of these seven should currently be described as already live in checked Unreal surfaces
+- all seven remain retained permissive candidates rather than landed implementation lanes
+
+## Packet outcome summary
+
+Packet result:
+
+- retained: `7`
+- discarded: `0`
+- newly proven live: `0`
+
+Resulting retained-set structure:
+
+- primary runtime-side hyper anchor:
+  - `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`
+- primary recognition anchor:
+  - `kkoomen/qbr`
+- secondary recognition/reconstruction companion:
+  - `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+- focused early subsystem donor:
+  - `Aarav2709/KubeTimr`
+- primary non-Euclidean/topology donor:
+  - `roice3/MagicTile`
+- specialized later hyper donors:
+  - `roice3/Magic120Cell`
+  - `roice3/MagicCube5D`
+
+Most important scheduling consequence:
+
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr` is the only `Packet 0R-A` repo that currently looks like an early straight permissive subsystem implementation candidate after `Phase 2R`
+- the other six remain clearly retained, but they belong to later retained-set architecture and capability-widening waves rather than immediate direct widening
+
+## Packet decisions
+
+| Repo | License | Current live evidence | Phase 0R decision | Implementation lane | Scheduled restart phase |
+| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
+| `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain and ratify as primary runtime-side hypercubing foundation anchor | bounded first-party engine extraction, not product-shell transplant | `Phase 2R` retained-set architecture anchor, then `Phase 6R` simulation/hyper widening lead |
+| `kkoomen/qbr` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain and ratify as primary live-recognition anchor | bounded permissive CV sidecar/service and calibration/state-reconstruction donor | `Phase 2R` recognition contract anchor, then `Phase 6R` recognition widening lead |
+| `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain as secondary recognition and reconstruction companion behind `qbr` | bounded browser/service contract and explainability companion donor | `Phase 2R` recognition companion design, then `Phase 6R` recognition/browser explanation widening |
+| `Aarav2709/KubeTimr` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain as focused subsystem donor; do not promote to training-platform owner | straight permissive first-party timer, inspection, split, and session-stat subsystem implementation | `Phase 2R` timer contract freeze, then earliest `Phase 3R` permissive implementation candidate |
+| `roice3/MagicTile` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain and effectively promote within the hyper donor cluster as top-tier geometry/topology donor | bounded first-party geometry/topology extraction, not runtime-base replacement | `Phase 2R` hyper architecture design anchor, then `Phase 6R` non-Euclidean and topology widening |
+| `roice3/Magic120Cell` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain as specialized `4D` interaction donor | bounded first-party advanced interaction and visibility extraction | later `Phase 6R` hyper widening after `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile` |
+| `roice3/MagicCube5D` | `MIT` | no exact live-surface match found | retain as specialized `5D` cube-family UX donor | bounded first-party advanced cube-family UX and macro/progress extraction | later `Phase 6R` hyper widening after `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile` |
+
+## Repo-by-repo notes
+
+### `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains the strongest runtime-side hypercubing foundation in the current retained set
+- is already decomposed like a platform, not a thin app shell
+- should shape engine-level boundaries, notation/state separation, puzzle definition, and simulation/view-state layering
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- ratify as the primary runtime-side hyper foundation anchor
+- do not treat it as a full product-shell transplant
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- use it in `Phase 2R` to freeze hyper-runtime and simulation boundary decisions
+- schedule actual donor realization in `Phase 6R`, not as immediate post-reset widening
+
+### `kkoomen/qbr`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains the best current anchor for live cube recognition, calibration, color normalization, and sticker-grid state extraction
+- is narrow but exactly narrow in the right direction
+- should define the recognition nucleus, not the whole product shell
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- ratify as the primary recognition anchor
+- keep it ahead of `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- use it in `Phase 2R` to freeze recognition-side contracts, calibration expectations, and CV session seams
+- schedule actual donor realization in `Phase 6R`
+
+### `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains strong enough to stay in the retained set
+- is most useful as the bridge between CV-derived state reconstruction, browser-facing correction, websocket flow, and stepwise explanation
+- should complement `qbr`, not replace it
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- retain as secondary recognition and reconstruction companion
+- do not elevate above `qbr`
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- use it in `Phase 2R` for browser correction flow, websocket session contracts, and explanation-flow companion decisions
+- schedule actual donor realization in `Phase 6R`
+
+### `Aarav2709/KubeTimr`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains a narrow but clean timer/practice subsystem donor
+- is useful for timer-state logic, inspection handling, split capture, rolling session statistics, and local persistence fallbacks
+- is too small and too narrow to own the training pillar
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- retain as a focused subsystem donor
+- explicitly reject any reading that treats it as already live or as a broader training-platform owner
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- use it in `Phase 2R` to freeze timer, inspection, split, and session-stat contracts
+- treat it as the earliest `Packet 0R-A` repo that can likely move into a real `Phase 3R` permissive implementation slice
+
+### `roice3/MagicTile`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains one of the most important geometry/topology donors in the retained set
+- is stronger than the stale older CSV posture suggested
+- belongs below `Hyperspeedcube` as runtime base, but above generic donor-bench interpretations
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- effectively promote within the hyper donor cluster
+- ratify it as the primary non-Euclidean and topology-aware donor
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- use it in `Phase 2R` for geometry-family, topology, and non-Euclidean expansion decisions
+- schedule actual donor realization in `Phase 6R`
+
+### `roice3/Magic120Cell`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains worth keeping, but clearly as a specialized later donor
+- adds real `4D` visibility, filtering, undo/history, and advanced teaching-surface value
+- should stay below `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile`
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- retain as a specialized `4D` interaction donor
+- do not promote to foundation status
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- schedule after `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile` in `Phase 6R`
+
+### `roice3/MagicCube5D`
+
+Source-backed reading:
+
+- remains worth keeping as a specialized later donor
+- adds real `5D` cube-family UX, macro, progress, slice-control, and teaching-surface value
+- should stay below `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile`
+
+Phase `0R` call:
+
+- keep
+- retain as a specialized `5D` cube-family UX donor
+- do not promote to foundation status
+
+Practical scheduling call:
+
+- schedule after `Hyperspeedcube` and `MagicTile` in `Phase 6R`
+
+## Net packet interpretation changes
+
+This packet closes several ambiguities:
+
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr` remains retained, but it is not live and it is not the owner of the broader training architecture
+- `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube` remains the primary hyper runtime anchor
+- `kkoomen/qbr` remains the primary recognition anchor
+- `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver` remains retained as a companion rather than the primary base
+- `roice3/MagicTile` deserves stronger retained importance than the older shallow read suggested
+- `roice3/Magic120Cell` and `roice3/MagicCube5D` survive, but as later specialized donors rather than early anchors
+
+## Packet-close result
+
+`Packet 0R-A` is now source-backed, scheduled, and no longer just a placeholder name.
+
+It is closed as an evaluation packet.
+
+The next best clean move is:
+
+1. open `Packet 0R-B`
+2. evaluate the remaining retained permissive donors
+3. keep `Phase 3R+` widening frozen until the broader `Phase 0R` retained set is actually closed
--- a/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_EVALUATION_RESET_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_SCHEDULE_2026-05-11.md
+++ b/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_EVALUATION_RESET_AND_IMPLEMENTATION_SCHEDULE_2026-05-11.md
@ -20,6 +20,25 @@ The current restart authority addendum is:

 Use that document when a future session needs the cross-location restart authority order, the stale-doc demotions, and the explicit post-`Phase 1R` sequence.

+## 2026-05-12 Packet 0R-A status
+
+The first `Phase 0R` packet is now closed as an evaluation packet:
+
+- `Packet 0R-A` result doc:
+  - `docs/HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md`
+
+Packet result:
+
+- retained: `7`
+- discarded: `0`
+- newly proven live: `0`
+
+Most important scheduling result:
+
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr` is the earliest `Packet 0R-A` straight permissive subsystem implementation candidate after `Phase 2R`
+- `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`, `kkoomen/qbr`, and `roice3/MagicTile` are retained-set architecture anchors
+- `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`, `roice3/Magic120Cell`, and `roice3/MagicCube5D` remain retained later companions/donors
+
 Use it when a future model, operator, or reviewer needs one unambiguous answer to all of the following:

 - what is already implemented right now
@ -255,6 +274,18 @@ Expected outcome:
  - bounded adapter/dependency use
  - or discard if deep evaluation shows weak real value

+Current packet result:
+
+- `Packet 0R-A` is now closed for:
+  - `Aarav2709/KubeTimr`
+  - `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`
+  - `kkoomen/qbr`
+  - `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+  - `roice3/MagicTile`
+  - `roice3/Magic120Cell`
+  - `roice3/MagicCube5D`
+- next clean permissive packet is `0R-B`
+
 ### Wave `2` — permissive browser, analytics, XR, and support stack evaluation

 Deep-evaluate next:
--- a/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_STATE_BOARD_2026-05-11.md
+++ b/docs/HYPERTWIST_REPO_STATE_BOARD_2026-05-11.md
@ -12,6 +12,26 @@ This board is the readable row-by-row companion to the v6.3 CSVs. It is derived
 - Live restrictive clean-room lanes: `1`
 - Remaining rows requiring `Phase 0R` deep repo evaluation: `65`

+## 2026-05-12 packet overlay
+
+The baseline counts above do not change yet, but the first retained permissive evaluation packet is now closed.
+
+Read together with:
+
+- [HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md](C:/HyperTwist/docs/HYPERTWIST_PHASE_0R_PACKET_0R_A_EVALUATION_2026-05-12.md:1)
+
+That overlay closes evaluation for:
+
+- `HactarCE/Hyperspeedcube`
+- `kkoomen/qbr`
+- `vivaansinghvi07/rubix-cube-solver`
+- `Aarav2709/KubeTimr`
+- `roice3/MagicTile`
+- `roice3/Magic120Cell`
+- `roice3/MagicCube5D`
+
+The packet result keeps all seven retained, proves none of them live, and narrows their implementation lanes and restart sequencing.
+
 ## Count by live-state class

 - `implemented_live_permissive`: `5`