# HyperTwist Phase 4 review finalization carryover continuity packet

Created on `2026-05-06`

Status:

- first-party HyperTwist packet
- bounded Phase `4` coach-to-review validation slice

## Purpose

This packet closes the next review-finalization continuity gap in the live recognition-assisted coach-to-review loop.

The open task is:

- preserve unfinished review carryover and coach-pressure state when a review run is explicitly completed before the underlying review plan is actually exhausted

It is not:

- a new recognition transport packet
- a new review-policy heuristic packet
- a queue packet
- a broad review-plan redesign

## Scope

Bounded lane:

- fix the explicit review-run finalization path so it no longer force-closes review plans that still have non-terminal work
- let the existing review-plan normalizer decide whether the plan is actually complete after finalization-state adjustments
- keep the change local to repository-layer review-plan closure behavior

Out of scope:

- new replay scoring
- new dashboard layout work
- broader coach-action or queue heuristics

## Why this was the right next packet

Before this slice:

- queue-backed brief continuity, queue-launch continuity, and review-start summary continuity were already landed
- the review-program summary already shaped downstream coach pressure, source review-plan linkage, and dashboard-adjacent inspection
- review attempts and review-run finalization already refreshed repository views in the subsystem

But the explicit review-finalization rule still had one hard continuity break:

- `FinalizeReviewPlan()` unconditionally set `bCompleted = true`
- it then converted the current entry back to `Pending` for non-aborted completion or `Skipped` for abort
- completed plans are excluded from pending-plan and carryover accounting in `DeriveReviewProgramSummary()`

That meant a review run could end with unresolved review work still present, while the repository summary and downstream coach state treated the plan as fully closed.

The practical consequence was:

- carryover pressure could disappear from `PendingPlanCount`, `CarryoverCaseCount`, `CurrentPlanId`, and `bNeedsCoachIntervention`
- post-review coach feedback could read as if the review program had cleanly closed when it had only been interrupted

So the next honest move was:

- stop force-closing review plans at explicit run finalization and let the normalized plan state decide whether closure is real

## What landed

Primary code changes:

- `UnrealHyperTwist/Source/UnrealHyperTwist/Private/HyperTwistTraining/HyperTwistTrainingRepositoryLibrary.cpp`
  - `FinalizeReviewPlan()` no longer forces `bCompleted = true`
  - `FinalizeReviewPlan()` now passes the adjusted plan through `NormalizeReviewPlanState()`, so completion is derived from actual terminal entry state instead of being asserted up front

## Product effect

Explicit review-run completion is now more truthful:

- unfinished review work stays represented as open carryover when the review plan still has non-terminal entries
- review-program summary closure no longer drops carryover pressure just because the active run ended
- downstream coach memory, coach brief derivation, and dashboard-adjacent state keep seeing the correct post-review pressure
- fully exhausted review plans still close normally through the existing normalizer

## Acceptance criteria

- explicit review-run completion no longer force-closes review plans that still contain non-terminal entries
- unfinished review carryover remains visible in repository-derived review-program summary state
- post-review coach feedback no longer loses pressure from artificially closed review plans
- full product build succeeds

## Validation checklist

1. build `UnrealHyperTwist.sln` / `UnrealHyperTwistEditor`
2. confirm `FinalizeReviewPlan()` no longer sets `bCompleted = true` unconditionally
3. confirm finalization now routes through `NormalizeReviewPlanState()`
4. confirm open review carryover can survive explicit run completion into repository-derived summary state
5. confirm no broader queue or review-policy packet is reopened

That is the packet.
