Audits petergyang/human-review and ships a conceptual derivation that fits this
repo's stdlib-only conventions.
Audit (audit/human-review-2026-08/AUDIT.md): upstream is a well-engineered ~5,200
LOC Node app — its own test suite passes 90/90, and its security model (loopback
bind, DNS-rebinding Host check, constant-time token compare, realpath traversal
guard, inert Markdown renderer, 45-min idle shutdown) is better than most
local-server tools. It still does not fit: Node 20 + an npm runtime dependency
fails the same stdlib-only test that kept the heavier skillopt package out in
v2.11.2. Seven findings, three material — F1 (HIGH) unpinned `npx -y` executes a
newly published version on every run; F2 (MED) "do not end your turn" plus
re-poll on timeout with no headless guard or retry cap; F3 (MED) only /api/* is
token-gated.
Also: despite the name it is not a humanizer. This is human approval, not human
voice — no overlap with behuman or content-humanizer.
New plugin engineering/human-gate, three stdlib scripts, no server or socket:
- review_page_builder.py — Markdown/HTML to a single-file anchored review page
with zero network requests (~11 KB, opens over file://). Escapes before
applying inline markup, scheme-allowlists hrefs, drops script/style on HTML
input.
- feedback_parser.py — sidecar to batch.v1 JSON. BLOCKER/MAJOR/MINOR/NIT
(matching md-review) plus EDIT/NOTE/APPROVE. Verifies quotes against the real
file; strips HTML comments so a documented example cannot parse as a real
sign-off.
- human_gate.py — open/status/collect/close/reset with atomic writes and
0700/0600 state. Rules G1-G6 refuse to close on: no collected round, an open
BLOCKER/MAJOR, an unnamed reviewer, a sidecar changed after collection, an
exhausted round cap (exit 5 = escalate), or an undocumented waiver.
Loop discipline deliberately inverts upstream: no blocking poll, a headless
guard, a round cap that escalates. The sidecar is hand-writable Markdown, so the
loop closes over SSH and in CI. The optional bridge to upstream is opt-in and
always version-pinned.
Adds 3 references (7-8 sources each), a batch.v1 schema, a worked example,
cs-human-gate agent, /cs:human-gate command. SKILL.md passes the write-a-skill
6-item checklist 6/6; description validator PASS.
Counters: skills 362->363, tools 644->647, refs 741->744, agents 102->103,
commands 116->117, plugins 88->89.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01233Eggb2cjSYf96X6C3pCm
