mirror of
https://github.com/abhigyanpatwari/GitNexus.git
synced 2026-09-24 00:51:53 +00:00
a2a274c9cf
Addresses the three high-severity findings from the Codex adversarial review of PR #744 (https://github.com/abhigyanpatwari/GitNexus/pull/744#issuecomment-4212075120), plus four deeper fixes discovered during regression triage. All discovered issues are now addressed end-to-end rather than papered over with tail-return fallbacks. Codex review findings: R1 (C++ diamond): The cpp-diamond-inheritance fixture used non-virtual inheritance, which is genuinely ambiguous in real C++ (two Base subobjects). Changed A and B to use 'virtual public Base' so there's a single shared Base subobject and d.method() is an unambiguous call that the leftmost-base MRO walk correctly resolves. R2 (C# default-interface): The csharp-interface-default-method fixture called user.Validate() via a User-typed variable, but C# does not inherit default interface methods as callable class members — the call is only valid through an interface-typed variable. Changed App.cs to 'IValidator user = new User(...)' which is the idiomatic dispatch pattern. R3 (resolveCallTarget tail-return): When D1-D4 receiver filtering produced zero file-matched and zero owner-matched candidates for a member call, the function fell through to the permissive single-candidate tail return — silently emitting CALLS edges for methods that don't belong to the receiver. Added an explicit null-route inside the D1-D4 block that fires only when both filters yielded 0. R4 (Rust negative assertion): Added the c.trait_only() negative integration test in rust.test.ts demonstrating that direct member calls on Rust structs do not walk trait ancestry. The test now passes because of R3 (previously fell through to the tail return). Regression triage discoveries: 1. D0 was dead code on the sequential pipeline. The sequential path sets overloadHints for every call regardless of whether the method is overloaded, and the original D0 skip condition '!overloadHints && !preComputedArgTypes' was therefore always false. The Java/C#/C++ SM-9/SM-10 inheritance tests were passing ONLY via the tail-return fallback. Fix: narrow the skip to 'overloadHints && filteredCandidates.length > 1' — skip D0 only when there are actually multiple candidates that need overload disambiguation. 2. lookupMethodByOwner couldn't disambiguate arity-differing overloads (e.g. C++ greet() vs greet(string)). With D0 now firing on the sequential path, same-name/different-arity overloads would collapse to an arbitrary first pick. Fix: added an optional argCount parameter to lookupMethodByOwner + lookupMethodByOwnerWithMRO that filters the overload set by parameterCount/requiredParameterCount before the returnType dedup. 3. Python and Rust class methods are captured as Function nodes (not Method) with ownerId set to the class. The methodByOwner index only accepted 'Method' and 'Constructor' types, so Python class methods and Rust trait methods were invisible to D0. Fix: extended the methodByOwner indexing condition to include 'Function' when ownerId is set. This also unlocks the Rust trait-method negative assertion by ensuring the qualified-syntax MRO strategy has something to return null for. 4. D0 was being skipped when a local variable shadowed an imported module name (Python 'from models.c import C; c = C()' creates both a module alias 'c → models/c.py' AND a typed local 'c'). Fix: the D0 skip now gates on 'aliasNarrowed' (a new boolean tracking whether the alias block actually narrowed filteredCandidates) instead of 'hasActiveModuleAlias'. If the method isn't in the aliased module, the receiver is a typed local variable and D0 should run. 5. PHP trait walk missed the HasTimestamps trait because lookupClassByName did not include 'Trait' type. buildHeritageMap uses lookupClassByName to resolve parent names, so 'BaseModel use HasTimestamps' was failing to register an ancestor edge for BaseModel → HasTimestamps. Fix: added 'Trait' to CLASS_TYPES. The trait is now a valid class-like type for heritage resolution (PHP use, Rust impl Trait for Struct, Scala traits). Test updates: - Updated the 'no heritageMap' unit test in call-processor.test.ts to assert the correct null-route behavior instead of the old tail-return fallback. - Added a new unit test asserting Trait inclusion in the class set. - Updated the 'does NOT include other type-like labels' test to remove Trait from its rejection set. Verification: - tsc --noEmit: clean - vitest run test/unit/: 3016 passed (+1 new Trait inclusion test) - vitest run test/integration/resolvers/: 1764 passed (+1 new Rust negative assertion) - Zero regressions |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| call-routing | ||
| group | ||
| import-resolution | ||
| named-bindings | ||
| ai-context.test.ts | ||
| analyze-api.test.ts | ||
| analyze-job.test.ts | ||
| ast-cache.test.ts | ||
| bm25-search.test.ts | ||
| call-form.test.ts | ||
| call-processor.test.ts | ||
| calltool-dispatch.test.ts | ||
| cli-commands.test.ts | ||
| cli-index-help.test.ts | ||
| cobol-copy-expander.test.ts | ||
| cobol-preprocessor.test.ts | ||
| cohesion-consistency.test.ts | ||
| community-processor.test.ts | ||
| compatible-stdio-transport.test.ts | ||
| cors.test.ts | ||
| csv-escaping.test.ts | ||
| dart-import-resolver.test.ts | ||
| dart-type-extractor.test.ts | ||
| embedder.test.ts | ||
| entry-point-scoring.test.ts | ||
| eval-formatters.test.ts | ||
| expo-routes.test.ts | ||
| extract-element-type-from-string.test.ts | ||
| extract-generic-type-args.test.ts | ||
| fetch-reason-parsing.test.ts | ||
| field-extraction.test.ts | ||
| framework-detection.test.ts | ||
| git-clone.test.ts | ||
| git-utils.test.ts | ||
| git.test.ts | ||
| graph.test.ts | ||
| has-method.test.ts | ||
| heritage-map.test.ts | ||
| heritage-processor.test.ts | ||
| hooks.test.ts | ||
| http-embedder.test.ts | ||
| hybrid-search.test.ts | ||
| ignore-service.test.ts | ||
| impact-batching-grouping.test.ts | ||
| impact-confidence.test.ts | ||
| import-processor.test.ts | ||
| index-repo-command.test.ts | ||
| ingestion-utils.test.ts | ||
| isWriteQuery.test.ts | ||
| jcl-parser.test.ts | ||
| language-skip.test.ts | ||
| lazy-action.test.ts | ||
| method-extraction.test.ts | ||
| method-props.test.ts | ||
| mro-processor.test.ts | ||
| noise-filter.test.ts | ||
| parser-loader.test.ts | ||
| pipeline-exports.test.ts | ||
| process-processor.test.ts | ||
| repo-manager.test.ts | ||
| resources.test.ts | ||
| route-tool-detection.test.ts | ||
| run-analyze.test.ts | ||
| schema.test.ts | ||
| security.test.ts | ||
| sequential-language-availability.test.ts | ||
| server.test.ts | ||
| setup-codex.test.ts | ||
| setup.test.ts | ||
| shape-check.test.ts | ||
| shared-type-extractors.test.ts | ||
| skill-gen.test.ts | ||
| skip-git-cli.test.ts | ||
| staleness.test.ts | ||
| stdout-silence.test.ts | ||
| structure-processor.test.ts | ||
| suffix-index-ambiguity.test.ts | ||
| symbol-resolver.test.ts | ||
| symbol-table.test.ts | ||
| tools.test.ts | ||
| topological-sort.test.ts | ||
| tree-sitter-queries.test.ts | ||
| type-env.test.ts | ||
| utils.test.ts | ||
| vue-sfc-extractor.test.ts | ||
| wiki-flags.test.ts | ||
| wiki-llm-client.test.ts | ||