GitNexus/gitnexus-shared/src/scope-resolution/scope-tree.ts
ManniX-ITA f482e7282a fix(scope-resolution): allow same-range Module-as-parent for top-level scopes (closes #1086) (#1087)
* fix(scope-resolution): allow same-range Module-as-parent for top-level scopes (closes #1086)

When a C# file consists of a single top-level `namespace_declaration` that
ends exactly at EOF (no trailing newline, no leading content outside the
namespace's `{}` body), tree-sitter-c-sharp 0.23.1 reports identical byte
ranges for `compilation_unit` and `namespace_declaration`. Pre-fix the
scope-extractor parent-finder relied on strict containment, so the Module
was popped off the stack and the Namespace ended up with `parent === null`
→ `ScopeTreeInvariantError: non-module-requires-parent` →
`extractParsedFile` swallowed the throw and the whole file was dropped
from the registry-primary path. Cross-file IMPORTS / CALLS edges
originating in or terminating at that file vanished.

Hit on three real-world `*.Designer.cs` files in PersistentWindows
(`HotKeyWindow.Designer.cs`, `LaunchProcess.Designer.cs`,
`DbKeySelect.Designer.cs`) — all have the byte signature
`<BOM><CRLF>namespace ... { ... }<EOF>` (last hex = `... 7D 0D 0A 7D`).

The fix is a single carve-out in the parent-validity contract: a `Module`
may parent a same-range non-`Module` child. The relationship stays
acyclic because the carve-out is direction-asymmetric — only Module-as-
outer parents a same-range non-Module, never the reverse.

Two coordinated changes:

* `gitnexus/src/core/ingestion/scope-extractor.ts` — `pass1BuildScopes`
  now consults a new `canParentScope` helper instead of
  `rangeStrictlyContains` directly. Sort tie-breaker added so a same-
  range Module always sorts before a non-Module candidate, ensuring the
  Module lands on the parent-stack first regardless of tree-sitter
  capture iteration order.

* `gitnexus-shared/src/scope-resolution/scope-tree.ts` — `buildScopeTree`'s
  `parent-must-contain-child` check now uses the same `canParentScope`
  carve-out so the validator agrees with the extractor on what a
  well-formed parent edge looks like. Error message updated to spell
  out the new contract.

`rangeStrictlyContains` keeps its strict semantics in both files —
position-index lookups, hook-side range comparisons, and other call
sites are unchanged.

* `gitnexus/test/fixtures/lang-resolution/csharp-namespace-as-root-no-trailing-newline/`
  — minimal regression fixture mirroring the PersistentWindows shape:
  both `Models/User.cs` and `App/Program.cs` end exactly on the closing
  `}` of their namespace with no trailing newline. The trigger is shape-
  driven, not size-driven, so the fixture stays small (~250 bytes total).
* New `csharp.test.ts` describe block: scope extraction completes for
  both files, and the cross-file `IMPORTS` edge resolves through the
  scope-resolution path with `reason: 'csharp-scope: using'`.
* `scope-tree.test.ts`: replaced the prior "rejects child ranges
  identical to the parent" case with three new ones — non-Module parent
  still rejected at equal range; Module-as-parent of a same-range non-
  Module accepted (the #1086 carve-out); Module-as-parent of another
  Module still rejected (the asymmetry guard).

* `npx vitest run test/unit/scope-resolution test/integration/resolvers`
  → 2514 passed / 77 skipped / 0 failed (52 test files).
* `npx tsc --noEmit` clean in both `gitnexus/` and `gitnexus-shared/`.
* End-to-end on PersistentWindows (after rebuilding the Docker image
  with this branch): 3 prior `scope extraction failed for *.Designer.cs`
  warnings → 0. Pre-fix index numbers will be re-checked here once the
  branch is built and indexed; the existing post-#1082 baseline is
  1113 nodes / 2987 edges / 39 clusters / 97 flows.

`canParentScope` is language-agnostic. Other languages whose query emits
`(compilation_unit) @scope.module` plus a single same-range top-level
scope can naturally hit the same byte shape on minimal files; this fix
applies to all of them uniformly.

Refs: #1086 (issue with full root-cause analysis + 4-case empirical
repro through `extractParsedFile`).

* refactor(scope-resolution): export canParentScope from gitnexus-shared

Addresses #1087 review (medium): the helper was previously duplicated
byte-for-byte in `scope-extractor.ts` and `scope-tree.ts`. Per DoD
"single source of truth in shared", the contract piece belongs in
gitnexus-shared (Ring 2 SHARED #912) and the consuming layer should
import it. Eliminates the silent-drift surface where a future edit
to one copy would produce extractor/validator disagreement on what
a well-formed parent edge looks like.

Changes:
- gitnexus-shared/src/scope-resolution/scope-tree.ts: add `export`
  to `canParentScope`.
- gitnexus-shared/src/index.ts: re-export `canParentScope`.
- gitnexus/src/core/ingestion/scope-extractor.ts: remove the local
  `canParentScope` definition (and its now-unused local copy of
  `rangeStrictlyContains`), import from `gitnexus-shared`. The local
  `rangesEqual` stays — it's still used in capture-anchor logic at
  two unrelated sites.

Validation (per DoD §4.4 — both CLI and web consumers verified):
- npx tsc --noEmit clean in gitnexus/ and gitnexus-shared/
- cd gitnexus-web && npx tsc -b --noEmit clean
- gitnexus-shared `npm run build` clean
- Targeted: vitest run test/unit/scope-resolution test/integration/resolvers
  → 2522 passed / 0 failed / 77 skipped (54 files)
- Full suite: vitest run → 7238 passed / 1 failed / 97 skipped.
  The single failure is `test/unit/ignore-service.test.ts > warns
  on EACCES but does not throw`, which cannot run when uid=0 (root
  bypasses POSIX permission checks). Pre-existing on this branch
  before the refactor; unrelated to scope-resolution.
2026-04-27 11:06:54 +01:00

295 lines
11 KiB
TypeScript

/**
* `ScopeTree` — the lexical-scope spine of the `SemanticModel`
* (RFC §2.2 + §3.1; Ring 2 SHARED #912).
*
* Generalizes the `enclosingFunctions` pattern from closed PR #902 to
* arbitrary `ScopeKind`s. Owns the (parent ↔ children) relationship
* derived from each `Scope.parent` pointer, and validates the structural
* invariants a well-formed scope tree must satisfy.
*
* Invariants enforced at build time (throw on violation):
*
* - Every non-`Module` scope has a non-null parent.
* - Every parent pointer references a scope that was also supplied to
* `buildScopeTree`.
* - Parent range **strictly contains** child range.
* - Sibling ranges under the same parent do not overlap.
* - Parent and child live in the same `filePath`. (Cross-file parent
* pointers would be a category error — a `File` scope is not the
* parent of another file's scopes; imports do that job.)
*
* Satisfies the `ScopeLookup` contract (defined in `./types.js`), so
* `resolveTypeRef` (#916) and the scope-aware registries (#917) can take a
* `ScopeTree` directly without adapters.
*
* Immutable surface: `byId` is a `ReadonlyMap`; children arrays are
* `Object.freeze`d; miss lookups return a shared frozen empty array.
*/
import type { Scope, ScopeId, ScopeLookup, Range } from './types.js';
// ─── Public contract ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
export interface ScopeTree extends ScopeLookup {
readonly size: number;
readonly byId: ReadonlyMap<ScopeId, Scope>;
getScope(id: ScopeId): Scope | undefined;
getParent(id: ScopeId): Scope | undefined;
/** Child `ScopeId`s of `id`, in input order. Frozen empty array on miss. */
getChildren(id: ScopeId): readonly ScopeId[];
/**
* Ancestor chain from the immediate parent up to (and including) the
* root module scope. Excludes the starting scope itself. Frozen empty
* array on miss / for a root scope.
*/
getAncestors(id: ScopeId): readonly ScopeId[];
has(id: ScopeId): boolean;
}
// ─── Build errors ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
/**
* Thrown by `buildScopeTree` when the input violates a structural
* invariant. Carries the offending ids + the invariant name so failed
* extraction pipelines can report actionable diagnostics.
*/
export class ScopeTreeInvariantError extends Error {
constructor(
readonly invariant:
| 'non-module-requires-parent'
| 'parent-not-found'
| 'parent-must-contain-child'
| 'sibling-ranges-overlap'
| 'parent-must-share-filepath'
| 'duplicate-scope-id',
message: string,
) {
super(message);
this.name = 'ScopeTreeInvariantError';
}
}
// ─── Builder ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
/**
* Build an immutable `ScopeTree` from a flat list of `Scope` records.
*
* Throws `ScopeTreeInvariantError` on the first invariant violation; a
* malformed tree is a bug in the extraction pipeline, not a data case for
* consumers to handle, so fail-fast is the correct posture.
*/
export function buildScopeTree(scopes: readonly Scope[]): ScopeTree {
const byId = new Map<ScopeId, Scope>();
const childrenById = new Map<ScopeId, ScopeId[]>();
// ── Pass 1: collect by id + duplicate check ───────────────────────────
for (const scope of scopes) {
if (byId.has(scope.id)) {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'duplicate-scope-id',
`Two scopes share id '${scope.id}'. Scope ids must be unique per tree.`,
);
}
byId.set(scope.id, scope);
}
// ── Pass 2: validate parent pointers + build children buckets ─────────
for (const scope of scopes) {
if (scope.parent === null) {
if (scope.kind !== 'Module') {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'non-module-requires-parent',
`Scope '${scope.id}' has kind '${scope.kind}' but no parent. Only 'Module' scopes may be root-level.`,
);
}
continue;
}
const parent = byId.get(scope.parent);
if (parent === undefined) {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'parent-not-found',
`Scope '${scope.id}' references parent '${scope.parent}' which is not part of this tree.`,
);
}
if (parent.filePath !== scope.filePath) {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'parent-must-share-filepath',
`Scope '${scope.id}' (${scope.filePath}) has parent '${parent.id}' in a different file (${parent.filePath}). Parent/child scopes must share filePath.`,
);
}
if (!canParentScope(parent.range, scope.range, parent.kind, scope.kind)) {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'parent-must-contain-child',
`Parent scope '${parent.id}' at ${formatRange(parent.range)} does not contain child '${scope.id}' at ${formatRange(scope.range)} (allowed: strict containment, or equal-range Module-as-parent).`,
);
}
let bucket = childrenById.get(parent.id);
if (bucket === undefined) {
bucket = [];
childrenById.set(parent.id, bucket);
}
bucket.push(scope.id);
}
// ── Pass 3: sibling-overlap check ─────────────────────────────────────
for (const [parentId, childIds] of childrenById) {
if (childIds.length < 2) continue;
// Sort siblings by (startLine, startCol) for an O(n log n) pairwise
// scan instead of O(n²) all-pairs.
const children = childIds.map((id) => byId.get(id)!).slice();
children.sort((a, b) => comparePosition(a.range, b.range));
for (let i = 1; i < children.length; i++) {
const prev = children[i - 1]!;
const curr = children[i]!;
if (rangesOverlap(prev.range, curr.range)) {
throw new ScopeTreeInvariantError(
'sibling-ranges-overlap',
`Sibling scopes under parent '${parentId}' overlap: '${prev.id}' ${formatRange(prev.range)} and '${curr.id}' ${formatRange(curr.range)}.`,
);
}
}
}
// Freeze children arrays so the surface is truly read-only.
const frozenChildren = new Map<ScopeId, readonly ScopeId[]>();
for (const [parentId, childIds] of childrenById) {
frozenChildren.set(parentId, Object.freeze(childIds.slice()));
}
return freezeTree(byId, frozenChildren);
}
// ─── Internals ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
const EMPTY_CHILDREN: readonly ScopeId[] = Object.freeze([]);
function freezeTree(
byId: Map<ScopeId, Scope>,
childrenById: Map<ScopeId, readonly ScopeId[]>,
): ScopeTree {
return {
byId,
get size() {
return byId.size;
},
getScope(id: ScopeId): Scope | undefined {
return byId.get(id);
},
getParent(id: ScopeId): Scope | undefined {
const scope = byId.get(id);
if (scope === undefined || scope.parent === null) return undefined;
return byId.get(scope.parent);
},
getChildren(id: ScopeId): readonly ScopeId[] {
return childrenById.get(id) ?? EMPTY_CHILDREN;
},
getAncestors(id: ScopeId): readonly ScopeId[] {
const start = byId.get(id);
if (start === undefined || start.parent === null) return EMPTY_CHILDREN;
const out: ScopeId[] = [];
const visited = new Set<ScopeId>([id]);
let cursor: ScopeId | null = start.parent;
while (cursor !== null && !visited.has(cursor)) {
visited.add(cursor);
out.push(cursor);
const next = byId.get(cursor);
cursor = next === undefined ? null : next.parent;
}
return Object.freeze(out);
},
has(id: ScopeId): boolean {
return byId.has(id);
},
};
}
/**
* `outer` strictly contains `inner` when `outer`'s start is at or before
* `inner`'s start, `outer`'s end is at or after `inner`'s end, and they are
* not the exact same range. Equal ranges are rejected — a child cannot
* occupy the exact same span as its parent.
*/
function rangeStrictlyContains(outer: Range, inner: Range): boolean {
if (
outer.startLine === inner.startLine &&
outer.startCol === inner.startCol &&
outer.endLine === inner.endLine &&
outer.endCol === inner.endCol
) {
return false;
}
const outerStartsAtOrBefore =
outer.startLine < inner.startLine ||
(outer.startLine === inner.startLine && outer.startCol <= inner.startCol);
const outerEndsAtOrAfter =
outer.endLine > inner.endLine ||
(outer.endLine === inner.endLine && outer.endCol >= inner.endCol);
return outerStartsAtOrBefore && outerEndsAtOrAfter;
}
function rangesEqual(a: Range, b: Range): boolean {
return (
a.startLine === b.startLine &&
a.startCol === b.startCol &&
a.endLine === b.endLine &&
a.endCol === b.endCol
);
}
/**
* Whether `outer` (kind `outerKind`) is a valid parent for `inner` (kind
* `innerKind`).
*
* Strict containment is the general rule. The single carve-out is the
* `Module`/non-`Module` pair whose ranges are exactly equal — this happens
* naturally when tree-sitter reports identical byte spans for the
* `compilation_unit` (or equivalent file-root construct) and the file's
* single top-level scope. Common shape: a C# file consisting of nothing
* but `namespace X { ... }` with no leading or trailing trivia outside the
* namespace's `{}` body — `compilation_unit` and `namespace_declaration`
* both span exactly the same byte range. The `Module` is the universal
* outer of any file-level scope by language semantics, so coincident
* ranges should not break the parent chain.
*
* The carve-out is direction-asymmetric: only `Module`-as-outer parents a
* same-range non-`Module`, never the reverse. This preserves the
* acyclicity buildScopeTree relies on, and matches the corresponding
* helper in `scope-extractor.ts` so `pass1BuildScopes` and the validator
* agree on what a well-formed parent edge looks like.
*/
export function canParentScope(
outer: Range,
inner: Range,
outerKind: Scope['kind'],
innerKind: Scope['kind'],
): boolean {
if (rangeStrictlyContains(outer, inner)) return true;
if (outerKind === 'Module' && innerKind !== 'Module' && rangesEqual(outer, inner)) return true;
return false;
}
/**
* Two ranges overlap when neither finishes before the other begins. Ranges
* that merely touch at a single boundary point (`a.end === b.start`) do
* NOT overlap — this matches tree-sitter's half-open-like range semantics
* and the typical "sibling blocks meet but don't overlap" pattern.
*/
function rangesOverlap(a: Range, b: Range): boolean {
const aEndsBeforeB =
a.endLine < b.startLine || (a.endLine === b.startLine && a.endCol <= b.startCol);
const bEndsBeforeA =
b.endLine < a.startLine || (b.endLine === a.startLine && b.endCol <= a.startCol);
return !(aEndsBeforeB || bEndsBeforeA);
}
function comparePosition(a: Range, b: Range): number {
if (a.startLine !== b.startLine) return a.startLine - b.startLine;
return a.startCol - b.startCol;
}
function formatRange(r: Range): string {
return `${r.startLine}:${r.startCol}-${r.endLine}:${r.endCol}`;
}