mirror of
https://github.com/abhigyanpatwari/GitNexus.git
synced 2026-10-08 03:08:13 +00:00
152a0506c9
* feat: shared resilient-fetch (retries + circuit breaker)
Add a small, runtime-agnostic resilience layer in gitnexus-shared and
migrate every backend HTTP outbound call (CLI, MCP, wiki LLM, web → backend)
through it.
Helpers (gitnexus-shared/src/integrations/):
- retry.ts — withRetry(fn, opts) with caller-supplied
retryability classification and full-jitter
exponential backoff.
- circuit-breaker.ts — closed/open/half-open per-process breaker with
injectable clock, plus a keyed registry so
callers targeting the same endpoint share state.
- resilient-fetch.ts — composed wrapper: retries 5xx + 429 + retryable
network throws, treats AbortSignal.timeout()
and 4xx (other than 429) as terminal, honors
Retry-After (capped at 30s), throws
CircuitOpenError when the breaker opens.
Migrations (no behaviour regression — all existing tests pass):
- gitnexus/src/core/embeddings/http-client.ts (covers analyze + MCP
query path) — replaces inline linear-backoff retry.
- gitnexus/src/core/wiki/llm-client.ts — preserves Azure content-filter
branch; resilientFetch handles 5xx/429.
- gitnexus-web/src/services/backend-client.ts (fetchWithTimeout helper)
— small retry budget (2 attempts, 250–1500 ms) so a dead local
backend still fails fast for the user.
- gitnexus-web/src/core/llm/settings-service.ts (OpenRouter model list).
Deliberately not migrated:
- gitnexus-web/src/services/backend-client.ts streamJob() — Server-Sent
Events stream; the existing reconnect-with-Last-Event-ID logic is
not unary-fetch shaped.
- gitnexus-web/src/components/SettingsPanel.tsx checkOllamaStatus() —
one-shot health probe; retrying delays the "Ollama not running"
error rather than improving UX.
41 new helper tests cover backoff math, breaker state transitions,
Retry-After parsing (delta-seconds + HTTP-date), 401/422 terminal
classification, and breaker fail-fast on three exhausted retry batches.
* fix(review): apply autofix feedback
Address Claude's two MEDIUM blocking findings on PR #1448 plus the
CodeQL SSRF false-positive flag.
- backend-client `fetchWithTimeout` now uses `AbortSignal.timeout()`
merged with the caller's signal via `AbortSignal.any()`. Timer-fired
aborts surface as `DOMException(name='TimeoutError')` so
resilientFetch routes them through the terminal-network branch
(no retry, no breaker hit), instead of incrementing the breaker
for user-side network slowness.
- Method-aware retry budget in `fetchWithTimeout`: idempotent verbs
(GET/HEAD/OPTIONS) keep the 2-attempt budget; POST/PATCH/PUT/DELETE
default to single-attempt so a 5xx on `startAnalyze` cannot start
a duplicate job. New `forceRetry` parameter for callers that
know-idempotent mutations (e.g. DELETE of a known-deleted resource).
- `resilient-fetch.ts` carries a documented suppression for CodeQL
js/server-side-request-forgery on the inner fetch call. Every
concrete caller passes a hardcoded URL constant or a value from
configuration (env vars, saved settings); user request input never
flows into the URL parameter.
- New test file `backend-client-retry.test.ts` covers all three
paths: GET retries on 503, POST does not retry, timeout does not
increment the breaker.
* fix(resilient-fetch): address Codex adversarial findings
Closes the three blocking issues from Codex's review on PR #1448.
U1 — Add `recordNeutral()` to CircuitBreaker.
Third outcome path that's an explicit no-op for state and the
consecutive-failure counter. Distinct from `recordSuccess` (closes
the breaker) and `recordFailure` (may open it). Used for outcomes
that are neither evidence of backend health nor evidence of
backend failure.
U2 — Route terminal-client / terminal-network through `recordNeutral`.
Previously a 401 or local timeout called `recordSuccess`, which
reset `consecutiveFailures` to 0. A 5xx → 401 → 5xx → 401 → 5xx
sequence would NEVER trip the breaker because each 4xx in between
erased the running count. Also classify external `AbortError` as
terminal-network (was retryable-network), so caller-driven
cancellation no longer retries against an already-aborted signal
or counts toward breaker failures on exhaustion.
U3 — Per-origin breaker key in web `fetchWithTimeout`.
Was hardcoded to `'web-backend'` even though `_backendUrl` is
mutable via `setBackendUrl`. Switching backend URLs after a
circuit tripped on host-A would strand the user during the full
cooldown. Key is now `web-backend:<origin>`, so each backend URL
gets its own breaker state.
Tests: +5 recordNeutral, +4 resilient-fetch (interleaved 4xx/5xx,
external AbortError, prior-state preservation), +1 web switch-backend
regression. All 70 gitnexus integration tests + 15 web tests green.
* fix(resilient-fetch): tolerate header-less fetch mocks on 429
`classifyOutcome` called `resp.headers.get('Retry-After')` directly,
which crashed when a test stubs `fetch` with a plain object like
`{ ok: false, status: 429 }` (no `headers` field). Real `Response`
always has Headers, so this surfaces only in test setups, but the
helper has no business assuming caller-side correctness on this — the
defensive guard is cheap and a missing `Retry-After` falls through to
exponential-backoff retry like any 429 without the header.
Surfaced by `gitnexus/test/unit/http-embedder.test.ts > retries on
rate limit`, which the embeddings migration exercises against a
plain-object 429 stub. Locked in with a new
`classifies 429 from a header-less fetch mock without throwing` case.
* fix(review): apply autofix feedback
Closes findings from the third multi-agent review pass on PR #1448.
#1 (P1) callLLM had no per-attempt timeout
Wiki LLM calls passed no `signal` to resilientFetch; each of three
retry attempts could hang indefinitely on a frozen TCP connection.
Add `signal: AbortSignal.timeout(60_000)` so the per-attempt budget
matches what http-client.ts and backend-client.ts already provide.
#2 (P2) drop dead `lastRetryableResp` post-loop fallback
Variable was set in one switch arm but only read in unreachable code
after the loop. The retry loop always returns/throws on every
iteration. Keep only the defensive `throw` so TypeScript's
control-flow analysis still sees `Promise<Response>` as the return.
#5 (P2) gate test-only exports behind a subpath
`__resetBreakerRegistry__` and `classifyOutcome` were reachable from
the main `gitnexus-shared` barrel — production code calling
`__resetBreakerRegistry__` from a tool implementation would silently
nuke every circuit breaker process-wide. Move to a new
`gitnexus-shared/test-helpers` subpath export. Production callers
see the cleaner public API; tests import via the explicit
`gitnexus-shared/test-helpers` path.
#6 (P2) exhaustiveness guard on Outcome switch
Add a `default: const _: never = outcome` arm so a future sixth
`Outcome.kind` won't compile silently — it'll surface at the switch
site rather than fall through to a retry/no-retry default.
#9 (P3) document cumulative wall-clock budget
Add a "Cumulative wall-clock budget" paragraph to resilientFetch's
JSDoc explaining the worst-case total wait (`maxAttempts × (per-attempt
timeout + capDelayMs)` ≈ 60s with defaults) and pointing callers at
outer `AbortSignal.timeout()` when they want a tighter bound.
Deferred to follow-up PRs (per review's Auto-resolve recommendation):
- #3 idempotency knob to shared API (forceRetry into ResilientFetchOptions)
- #4 publish.ts migration to resilientFetch
- #7 parseRetryAfter past-HTTP-date / negative-seconds asymmetry
- #8 recordNeutral counter time-decay (documented breaker semantic)
* fix(circuit-breaker): gate half-open to a single in-flight probe
Closes the Codex adversarial-review finding on PR #1448 that flagged a
recovery-time thundering herd: when cooldown expired, every concurrent
caller transitioned the breaker to half-open and probed the still-
recovering dependency in lockstep, defeating the breaker's "fail fast"
promise.
U1 — probe-permit gate in CircuitBreaker.check()
Added a `probeInFlight: boolean` field. After cooldown expires, the
first `check()` admits the probe and consumes the permit; subsequent
callers throw `CircuitOpenError` with a configurable
`halfOpenRetryAfterMs` (default 1000ms) until the probe resolves.
Critical design point: `recordNeutral` now RELEASES the permit but
does NOT transition state. Without that split, a single `TimeoutError`
from per-attempt `AbortSignal.timeout` (which routes through neutral
classification) would permanently park the breaker in half-open. By
separating permit-release from state-resolution, we keep the
"neutral doesn't claim health" semantic without creating that wedge.
Other changes:
- `halfOpenRetryAfterMs` is now a constructor option for consumers
with long-running protected ops (LLM streaming, large uploads).
- `getState()` is documented as a pure read; the implicit
Open -> Half-Open transition lives in `check()` only, so tests
that inspect state never inadvertently consume a probe permit.
- `isProbeInFlight()` test-only accessor for assertion clarity.
- JSDoc on `check()` records the JS event-loop atomicity dependency
and the load-bearing `try/finally` pairing invariant.
U2 — End-to-end concurrency regression through resilientFetch
Three new scenarios in resilient-fetch.test.ts (26 -> 29):
- 3 concurrent calls + probe gets 200 -> 1 hits fetch, 2 throw
CircuitOpenError, breaker closes.
- 3 concurrent calls + probe gets 503 -> ResilientFetchExhaustedError
on probe; concurrent callers see halfOpenRetryAfterMs (1000ms);
fresh caller after probe resolves sees the FULL new cooldown
(10000ms), not the probe-in-flight default.
- Probe cancelled mid-flight via AbortError -> permit released,
state stays half-open, next caller becomes the new probe and
succeeds.
Plus 9 new circuit-breaker unit tests (16 -> 25) covering the permit
gate, recordNeutral-releases-permit semantic, fresh-cooldown distinction,
default vs configurable halfOpenRetryAfterMs, getState() purity, and
the three-probes-via-neutrals chain.
Total integration test count: 70 -> 82. All 106 gitnexus + 15 web
tests pass; both packages typecheck.
Maintainer decisions (deferred per plan 003 Open Questions):
- Plan 002's deferral judgement was reversed on Codex's argument
without new measurement / incident data. The reversal is defensible
on principle (Hystrix / Resilience4j alignment) but lacks workload-
driven evidence.
- Probe-blocked callers throw silently (no log / event hook). R4's
"no new public API" prevents adding observability; loosen if a
debug log on probe-blocked is wanted.
* refactor(embeddings): replace bespoke HF breaker with shared CircuitBreaker
Deleted the local `HfDownloadCircuitBreaker` class and the manual
retry loop in `withHfDownloadRetry`. Both are now backed by the
shared `gitnexus-shared` primitives:
- `hfDownloadCircuit` is `new CircuitBreaker({ failureThreshold,
cooldownMs, key: 'hf-download' })` — same state machine as before
PLUS the single-permit half-open gate that prevents recovery-time
stampedes when CLI + MCP embedders concurrently re-load the model.
- `withHfDownloadRetry` delegates the loop to `withRetry` from the
shared package. Per-attempt timeout (`withDownloadTimeout`),
network-vs-non-network classification, circuit recording, and the
`onRetry` callback wire through `withRetry`'s `isRetryable`
callback.
Behaviour preserved:
- Pre-flight `CIRCUIT_OPEN_TAG` rejection when the breaker is open.
- Mid-loop `CIRCUIT_OPEN_TAG` "opened after N consecutive failures"
when a network error trips the threshold.
- Non-network errors (e.g. CUDA unavailable) bypass retry and go
through `recordNeutral` instead of resetting the breaker's
failure-count progress.
- `onRetry(attempt+1, max, err)` fires only when there's a next
attempt, matching the prior semantic.
Generic CircuitBreaker gained two inspection accessors:
- `getOpenedAt(): number | null`
- `getCooldownMs(): number`
Used by `withHfDownloadRetry` to compute `secsUntilReset` without
consuming a probe permit (which `check()` would do).
Test consolidation: the 7 bespoke `HfDownloadCircuitBreaker`
state-machine tests in hf-env.test.ts were 1:1 duplicates of
existing tests in `circuit-breaker.test.ts` and were deleted.
Remaining 42 hf-env tests all pass; full integration sweep (148
gitnexus + 15 web) green.
|
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| call-routing | ||
| group | ||
| import-resolution | ||
| integrations | ||
| mcp | ||
| model | ||
| named-bindings | ||
| scope-resolution | ||
| shadow | ||
| ai-context.test.ts | ||
| analyze-api.test.ts | ||
| analyze-embeddings-limit.test.ts | ||
| analyze-job.test.ts | ||
| analyze-worker-timeout.test.ts | ||
| api-file-route.test.ts | ||
| api-graph-streaming.test.ts | ||
| ast-cache.test.ts | ||
| ast-utils.test.ts | ||
| binding-accumulator.test.ts | ||
| bm25-search.test.ts | ||
| call-attribution-issue-1166.test.ts | ||
| call-extraction.test.ts | ||
| call-form.test.ts | ||
| call-processor.test.ts | ||
| calltool-dispatch.test.ts | ||
| chunker.test.ts | ||
| cli-commands.test.ts | ||
| cli-index-help.test.ts | ||
| cli-message.test.ts | ||
| cobol-copy-expander.test.ts | ||
| cobol-preprocessor.test.ts | ||
| cohesion-consistency.test.ts | ||
| community-processor.test.ts | ||
| compatible-stdio-transport.test.ts | ||
| cors.test.ts | ||
| cpp-ue-preprocessor.test.ts | ||
| cross-file-impl.test.ts | ||
| cross-file.test.ts | ||
| csv-escaping.test.ts | ||
| dart-import-resolver.test.ts | ||
| dart-type-extractor.test.ts | ||
| embedder.test.ts | ||
| embedding-chunking.test.ts | ||
| embedding-config.test.ts | ||
| embedding-pipeline.test.ts | ||
| entry-point-scoring.test.ts | ||
| eval-formatters.test.ts | ||
| exact-search.test.ts | ||
| expo-routes.test.ts | ||
| extract-element-type-from-string.test.ts | ||
| extract-generic-type-args.test.ts | ||
| fetch-reason-parsing.test.ts | ||
| field-extraction.test.ts | ||
| framework-detection.test.ts | ||
| git-clone.test.ts | ||
| git-utils.test.ts | ||
| git.test.ts | ||
| graph.test.ts | ||
| group-service-not-found.test.ts | ||
| has-method.test.ts | ||
| heritage-extraction.test.ts | ||
| heritage-map.test.ts | ||
| heritage-processor.test.ts | ||
| hf-env.test.ts | ||
| hooks.test.ts | ||
| http-embedder.test.ts | ||
| hybrid-search.test.ts | ||
| ignore-service.test.ts | ||
| impact-batching-grouping.test.ts | ||
| impact-confidence.test.ts | ||
| import-processor.test.ts | ||
| import-resolver-factory.test.ts | ||
| index-repo-command.test.ts | ||
| ingestion-utils.test.ts | ||
| isWriteQuery.test.ts | ||
| jcl-parser.test.ts | ||
| language-skip.test.ts | ||
| lazy-action.test.ts | ||
| lbug-checkpoint.test.ts | ||
| lbug-config-wal.test.ts | ||
| lbug-embedding-hashes.test.ts | ||
| lbug-extension-loader.test.ts | ||
| lbug-readonly-error.test.ts | ||
| local-backend-maxbuffer.test.ts | ||
| logger.test.ts | ||
| max-file-size.test.ts | ||
| mcp-stdout-sentinel.test.ts | ||
| mcp-wal-feedback.test.ts | ||
| method-extraction.test.ts | ||
| method-props.test.ts | ||
| mro-processor.test.ts | ||
| noise-filter.test.ts | ||
| parse-diff-hunks.test.ts | ||
| parse-impl-fallback.test.ts | ||
| parser-loader.test.ts | ||
| parsing-worker-fallback.test.ts | ||
| phase-timer.test.ts | ||
| pipeline-exports.test.ts | ||
| pipeline-runner.test.ts | ||
| platform-capabilities.test.ts | ||
| pool-wal-recovery.test.ts | ||
| process-processor.test.ts | ||
| publish.test.ts | ||
| rate-limit.test.ts | ||
| receiver-extraction.test.ts | ||
| registry-primary-flag.test.ts | ||
| rel-csv-split.test.ts | ||
| repo-manager-finalize-invariant.test.ts | ||
| repo-manager.test.ts | ||
| resolve-enclosing-owner.test.ts | ||
| resources.test.ts | ||
| route-tool-detection.test.ts | ||
| ruby-self-call.test.ts | ||
| run-analyze.test.ts | ||
| schema.test.ts | ||
| security.test.ts | ||
| semantic-chunk-search.test.ts | ||
| sequential-language-availability.test.ts | ||
| server-validation.test.ts | ||
| server.test.ts | ||
| setup-codex.test.ts | ||
| setup-jsonc.test.ts | ||
| setup.test.ts | ||
| shape-check.test.ts | ||
| shared-type-extractors.test.ts | ||
| sibling-clone-drift.test.ts | ||
| skill-gen.test.ts | ||
| skip-git-cli.test.ts | ||
| staleness.test.ts | ||
| stdout-silence.test.ts | ||
| structure-processor.test.ts | ||
| suffix-index-ambiguity.test.ts | ||
| symbol-resolver.test.ts | ||
| symbol-table.test.ts | ||
| text-generator.test.ts | ||
| tool-direct-cli.test.ts | ||
| tool-process-linking.test.ts | ||
| tools.test.ts | ||
| topological-sort.test.ts | ||
| transitive-include-closure.test.ts | ||
| tree-sitter-queries.test.ts | ||
| type-env.test.ts | ||
| u8-redos-resource-exhaustion.test.ts | ||
| utils.test.ts | ||
| variable-extraction.test.ts | ||
| vue-sfc-extractor.test.ts | ||
| web-ui-serving.test.ts | ||
| wiki-flags.test.ts | ||
| wiki-llm-client.test.ts | ||
| wildcard-synthesis.test.ts | ||
| worker-pool-options.test.ts | ||