GitNexus/gitnexus/bench/cfg/measure.mjs
Gergő Magyar d8a256a03a
fix(taint): avoid false positives for guarded Git arguments (#3703)
* fix(taint): refine values after accepted guards

Preserve bounded value restrictions through local flows and function
summaries. Check the complete command against the modeled sink use
before suppressing a finding. Unknown paths and exhausted budgets
retain conservative findings.

Refs #3490

* fix(taint): preserve guard proof identities

Reject destructured/rest formals before they inherit a whole-argument
proof, and include transitive alias uses in bounded guard certificates.

Add worker regressions, argument-heavy scaling coverage and global
refinement fallback diagnostics.

Refs #3703

* perf(cfg): reuse scope and argument facts

Reduce duplicate native AST reads and allocation in TypeScript CFG collection
while preserving argument forwarding and malformed-input recovery.

Add regression cases and a portable paired benchmark with recorded results.

* test(cfg): distinguish validator cases

---------

Co-authored-by: Gergo Magyar <gergomagyar0@gmail.com>
2026-10-24 15:37:26 +01:00

906 lines
39 KiB
JavaScript
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters

This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.

/**
* Build-free CFG-construction measurement harness (#2081 M1).
*
* Times `collectFunctionCfgs` (the per-function CFG builder the parse worker
* runs on a `--pdg` run) on synthetic TS sources at two sizes, in three
* scenarios that each stress a distinct cost dimension:
* - `straight-line`: ONE function with N coalescing statements — stresses the
* basic-block text accumulation (the `extendBlock` path);
* - `many-functions`: N small branchy functions — stresses the collect walk +
* per-function build + the tree-sitter `namedChildren` accesses;
* - `branchy`: ONE function with N sequential `if`s — stresses block/edge
* growth within a single CFG.
*
* For each scenario it reports three scaling ratios at small→large
* (`(metric_large/metric_small)/(N_large/N_small)`: ~1.0 is linear, ~4.0 is the
* O(n²) shape the M1 perf review flagged for `extendBlock`'s concat chain):
* - TIME — wall-clock of `collectFunctionCfgs` (median of reps);
* - DISK — utf8 byte size of the serialized `cfgSideChannel` (what a `--pdg`
* run writes onto every ParsedFile shard);
* - MEMORY — retained JS heap of the `cfgSideChannel` payload, by the
* release-delta method (heap held minus heap after dropping it). Requires
* `node --expose-gc`; without it the heap metric is null and its gate skips.
* It also computes an order-independent sha256 fingerprint over the emitted
* blocks/edges of a fixed-size source — the correctness gate that a structural
* speedup must leave behavior-identical.
*
* Build-free: imports the `.ts` hotpaths through tsx
* (`node --expose-gc --import tsx bench/cfg/measure.mjs`). Parsing happens ONCE
* per size and the tree is reused across reps so the time measurement isolates
* CFG build cost, not tree-sitter parse time. `maxFunctionLines` is 0 (no cap)
* here on purpose — the bench measures the algorithm; the production default cap
* is a separate safety net (and would otherwise skip the large straight-line fn).
*
* Without args: prints one JSON object per scenario.
* With `--check`: asserts each scenario's fingerprint == its committed baseline
* (baselines.json) AND each of the time / disk / heap ratios is below its
* recorded budget; exits non-zero on any drift/regression.
*/
import fs from 'node:fs';
import path from 'node:path';
import crypto from 'node:crypto';
import { fileURLToPath } from 'node:url';
import Parser from 'tree-sitter';
import { collectFunctionCfgs } from '../../src/core/ingestion/cfg/collect.ts';
import { computeReachingDefs } from '../../src/core/ingestion/cfg/reaching-defs.ts';
import {
DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_REACHING_DEF_FACTS_PER_FUNCTION,
DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_REACHING_DEF_BLOCK_REVISITS,
} from '../../src/core/ingestion/cfg/emit.ts';
import { getTreeSitterBufferSize } from '../../src/core/ingestion/constants.ts';
import { getLanguageGrammar } from '../../src/core/tree-sitter/parser-loader.ts';
import { getProvider } from '../../src/core/ingestion/languages/index.ts';
import { SupportedLanguages } from '../../src/config/supported-languages.ts';
import { buildTaintImportIndex, matchFunctionSites } from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/match.ts';
import { TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL } from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/typescript-model.ts';
import {
computeTaintFlows,
DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_TAINT_HOPS,
} from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/propagate.ts';
import { encodeTaintPath } from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/path-codec.ts';
import { createMemoizedRefinement } from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/guard-refinement.ts';
import { harvestFunctionSummary } from '../../src/core/ingestion/taint/summary-harvest.ts';
const __dirname = path.dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url));
const BASELINE_PATH = path.resolve(__dirname, 'baselines.json');
// ---- per-language registry (the U1 parameterization, #2195) ----
//
// A scenario names a `lang` (default 'ts'); the registry resolves its grammar,
// CFG visitor, and (optional) taint model GENERICALLY — the grammar via the
// production `getLanguageGrammar` loader and the visitor via the provider's
// `cfgVisitor` hook (the same seam `cfg-snapshot.test.ts` uses). No language is
// named in the bench logic itself: adding a language is one row here, not a new
// static grammar import (the language-naming anti-pattern). Lazy by design —
// only languages actually referenced by a scenario are loaded, so a missing
// optional grammar never breaks an unrelated run.
//
// - `grammar` — SupportedLanguages enum value for `getLanguageGrammar`.
// - `taintModel` — source/sink config threaded into the taint pass. ONLY the
// TS row carries `TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL`; C-family rows have no
// model (matching prod: `getSourceSinkConfig(<c-lang>)` is
// `undefined`), so the TS model never runs against a
// C-family CFG.
const LANGS = {
ts: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.TypeScript, taintModel: TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL },
go: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.Go, taintModel: null },
java: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.Java, taintModel: null },
c: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.C, taintModel: null },
cpp: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.CPlusPlus, taintModel: null },
csharp: { grammar: SupportedLanguages.CSharp, taintModel: null },
};
// Lazily build + cache one { parser, visitor, parse, taintModel } toolkit per
// language id. The parser is created once and reused across parses/reps for that
// language (parse cost is isolated from CFG-build cost by reusing the tree).
const langToolkitCache = new Map();
function langToolkit(langId) {
const cached = langToolkitCache.get(langId);
if (cached) return cached;
const spec = LANGS[langId];
if (!spec) throw new Error(`bench: unknown lang '${langId}' (add a row to LANGS)`);
const visitor = getProvider(spec.grammar).cfgVisitor;
if (!visitor)
throw new Error(`bench: provider for '${langId}' has no cfgVisitor (visitor not wired?)`);
const parser = new Parser();
parser.setLanguage(getLanguageGrammar(spec.grammar));
// Large synthetic sources exceed tree-sitter's default read buffer; size it
// from the content exactly as the parse worker does (getTreeSitterBufferSize).
const parse = (src) => parser.parse(src, undefined, { bufferSize: getTreeSitterBufferSize(src) });
const toolkit = { visitor, parse, taintModel: spec.taintModel };
langToolkitCache.set(langId, toolkit);
return toolkit;
}
// ---- synthetic generators (one cost dimension each) ----
const SCENARIOS = [
{
name: 'guard-free-arguments',
small: 1000,
large: 4000,
gen: (n) =>
Array.from(
{ length: n },
(_, i) => `function f${i}(x: string) { const y = 'prefix ' + x; return consume${i}(y); }`,
).join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'guarded-commands',
small: 60,
large: 240,
guard: { findingsPerFunction: 0 },
gen: (n) =>
Array.from(
{ length: n },
(_, i) => `function guarded${i}(req: any) {
const value: string = req.query.ref;
if (!/^[0-9a-f]{7,40}$/.test(value)) return;
execSync('git show ' + value);
}`,
).join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'guard-bypass',
small: 60,
large: 240,
guard: { findingsPerFunction: 1 },
gen: (n) =>
Array.from(
{ length: n },
(_, i) => `function bypass${i}(req: any, flag: boolean) {
const value: string = req.query.ref;
if (flag) { if (!/^[0-9a-f]{7,40}$/.test(value)) return; }
execSync('git show ' + value);
}`,
).join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'guard-forwarders',
small: 60,
large: 240,
guard: { findingsPerFunction: 0, forwarding: true },
gen: (n) =>
Array.from(
{ length: n },
(_, i) => `function forwarder${i}(value: string) {
if (!/^[0-9a-f]{7,40}$/.test(value)) return;
forward(value);
}`,
).join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'guard-capped',
small: 80,
large: 320,
guard: { findingsPerFunction: 1, fallback: true },
gen: (n) =>
`function capped(req: any) { const value: string = req.query.ref;\n` +
Array.from({ length: n }, () => 'if (!/^[0-9a-f]{7,40}$/.test(value)) return;').join('\n') +
`\nexecSync('git show ' + value); }`,
},
{
name: 'guard-discriminants',
small: 100,
large: 400,
guard: { findingsPerFunction: 0 },
gen: (n) =>
Array.from(
{ length: n },
(_, i) => `function discriminant${i}(kind: string) {
if (kind === 'read') return 1; return 2;
}`,
).join('\n'),
},
{
name: 'straight-line',
// One function, N coalescing simple statements → all fold into one basic
// block whose text is accumulated statement-by-statement (extendBlock).
// Uses LARGER sizes than the other scenarios: this scenario's only cost
// dimension is text accumulation (output size is constant — 4 blocks at any
// N — so the disk/heap ratios can't see it), so the TIME ratio is the sole
// guard against an extendBlock O(n²)-concat re-regression. At small N a
// quadratic is masked by V8 cons-strings + the linear tree-walk and slips
// under the budget; these larger sizes make a real quadratic separate
// cleanly (verified: a `+=` regression here exceeds the budget, the
// array-join impl stays ~1).
small: 2000,
large: 8000,
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f() {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` let v${i} = ${i} + 1;\n`;
return s + ' return v0;\n}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'many-functions',
// N independent small functions with a branch + return → stresses the
// tree walk in collectFunctionCfgs and the per-function build.
gen: (n) => {
let s = '';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) {
s += `function f${i}(x: number) { if (x > ${i}) { a(); } else { b(); } return x + ${i}; }\n`;
}
return s;
},
},
{
name: 'branchy',
// One function, N sequential `if`s → N condition blocks + 2N+ edges in a
// single CFG; stresses block/edge growth and namedChildren on the body.
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f(x: number) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` if (x > ${i}) { s${i}(); }\n`;
return s + '}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'dense-bindings',
// #2082 M2: N bindings live across ~N blocks inside one loop — bindings ×
// blocks scale JOINTLY, the discriminator for solver-lattice quadratics.
// The overlay design (KTD2: sets shared by reference, OUT spine-copied
// only on gen) is expected to scale ~linearly-with-a-spine-copy here
// (normalized ratio low single digits); the regression this scenario
// exists to catch is the repo's recurring per-item-rescan shape — a
// per-use scan over all defs (O(n³) here) blows the ratio past ~16.
// rd time is the gated metric (rd_scaling_budget).
rdMaxFacts: 0, // measure the algorithm, not the cap
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f(c: number) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` let v${i} = ${i};\n`;
s += ' while (c > 0) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` if (c > ${i}) { v${i} = v${(i + 1) % n} + 1; }\n`;
return s + ' c = c - 1;\n }\n return v0;\n}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'deep-nest',
// #2201: N nested loops carrying one variable end-to-end — the pathology the
// dense GEN/KILL worklist is superlinear on and that drives its block-visit
// total past the blocks×64 ceiling (it would truncate to an empty result).
// The production SSA solver is depth-INDEPENDENT (φ-nodes capture the loop
// merges statically; no fixpoint iteration), so rd time scales ~linearly
// with depth and the ceiling never fires. Two gates: rd_scaling_budget
// catches a regression back to superlinear, and facts_large_min asserts the
// solver still COMPUTES full facts under the PRODUCTION blocks×64 budget
// (rdProductionBudget) — a dense worklist would report zero facts here.
small: 40,
large: 160, // 4×, well under the visitor's recursive-nesting depth guard
rdMaxFacts: 0, // measure the algorithm, not the cap
rdProductionBudget: true, // pass blocks×64 — the SSA solver must still compute
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f(c: number) {\n let x = 0;\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ' '.repeat(i + 1) + `while (c > ${i}) {\n`;
s += ' '.repeat(n + 1) + 'x = x + 1;\n';
for (let i = n - 1; i >= 0; i--) s += ' '.repeat(i + 1) + '}\n';
return s + ' return x;\n}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'wide-merge',
// #2201 review R7: N bindings, each assigned in a 3-way branch (a WIDE φ
// merge per binding) inside a loop, then all used after the merge. Unlike
// dense-bindings (one chained redef per `if`), every binding here fans into
// its own multi-operand φ — so the scenario stresses φ-placement + renaming +
// the reachByScc condensation across MANY independent wide merges. N bindings
// × constant arms ⇒ O(N) facts, so the gate is rd_scaling LINEARITY: a
// regression to the per-binding-rescan class (O(N²), the recurring solver
// antipattern reachByScc's alias fast path guards against) blows the ratio.
// >=16 blocks + a reachable loop ⇒ the production SSA path.
rdMaxFacts: 0, // measure the algorithm, not the cap
rdProductionBudget: true, // prove the SSA path computes under blocks×64
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f(c: number) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` let v${i} = ${i};\n`;
s += ' while (c > 0) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) {
s +=
` if (c > ${i}) { v${i} = ${i} + c; }` +
` else if (c < ${i}) { v${i} = ${i} - c; }` +
` else { v${i} = c; }\n`;
}
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` use(v${i});\n`;
return s + ' c = c - 1;\n }\n return v0;\n}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'fact-fanout',
// #2082 M2: N parallel case-arm defs of one variable + N later uses —
// facts are O(defs×uses) BY SPEC, so a linearity ratio gate is the wrong
// shape. The gate here is BOUNDEDNESS: with the production fact limit
// engaged, the materialized fact count stays FLAT (== limit) as N grows
// past it (facts_large_max), and rd time stays bounded. An unbounded
// materialization regression (losing the maxFacts early-stop) shows as
// facts_large exploding quadratically.
rdMaxFacts: DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_REACHING_DEF_FACTS_PER_FUNCTION,
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'function f(c: number) {\n let x = 0;\n switch (c) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` case ${i}: x = ${i}; break;\n`;
s += ' }\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += ` u${i}(x);\n`;
return s + '}\n';
},
},
{
name: 'taint-dense',
// #2083 M3 U7 (R10): N functions, EACH source/sink-dense — 12 matched
// `req.body` source statements + a 4-hop chained reassignment + 13 `eval`
// sinks per function (13 deduped findings/fn, ABOVE the scenario cap of 8
// so the cap binds). Functions scale with N, so total findings grow
// linearly BY DESIGN; the boundedness gate is the per-function pin: kept
// findings/function stays EXACTLY at the cap as N grows (a cap loss shows
// as 13). This scenario's sites are the densest of the suite, so its
// ABSOLUTE disk_bytes_large_max is the load-bearing site-harvest ceiling
// (the M2 straight-line carrier has no call sites), and the summed
// encoded TAINTED reason bytes get their own absolute ceiling
// (taint_reason_bytes_large_max). The zero-match control (genZero) keeps
// the identical statement/CFG shape with names OUTSIDE the model
// (inp.payload / evalish) — the match-gate must make unmatched functions
// cost ~nothing (no solver call), gated as zero-time/dense-time ratio.
small: 125,
large: 500, // 4x, like the global sizes — per-fn bodies are ~30 lines
lang: 'ts', // taint model is TS-only; never run TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL on a C-family CFG
taint: { cap: 8 },
gen: (n) => genTaintFunctions(n, false),
genZero: (n) => genTaintFunctions(n, true),
},
{
name: 'go:branchy',
// #2195 U7: the first NON-TS scaling scenario — the C-family analogue of the
// TS `branchy` stressor, run through the Go grammar + Go CFG visitor. ONE Go
// function with N sequential `if`s → N condition blocks + 2N+ edges in a
// single CFG; stresses block/edge growth and the namedChildren walk on the
// Go body. The `go:` namespace keys it out of the TS baseline keyspace so a
// C-family entry can never collide with (or silently re-baseline) a TS
// scenario. CFG-only (Go has no registered taint model — see LANGS), so the
// gated metrics are the time/disk/heap/rd scaling ratios + the fingerprint.
lang: 'go',
gen: (n) => {
let s = 'package p\nfunc f(x int) {\n';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) s += `\tif x > ${i} {\n\t\ts${i}()\n\t}\n`;
return s + '}\n';
},
},
];
// taint-dense generator: `zero` swaps every model-matched name for an
// unmatched one without changing statement count, def/use shape, or CFG.
const TAINT_SOURCES_PER_FN = 12;
const TAINT_CHAIN_HOPS = 4;
function genTaintFunctions(n, zero) {
const recv = zero ? 'inp' : 'req';
const prop = zero ? 'payload' : 'body';
const sink = zero ? 'evalish' : 'eval';
let s = '';
for (let i = 0; i < n; i++) {
s += `function f${i}(${recv}) {\n`;
for (let j = 0; j < TAINT_SOURCES_PER_FN; j++) s += ` const s${j} = ${recv}.${prop};\n`;
s += ` let c0 = s0 + '!';\n`;
for (let h = 1; h < TAINT_CHAIN_HOPS; h++) s += ` const c${h} = c${h - 1} + '!';\n`;
for (let j = 0; j < TAINT_SOURCES_PER_FN; j++) s += ` ${sink}(s${j});\n`;
s += ` ${sink}(c${TAINT_CHAIN_HOPS - 1});\n`;
s += '}\n';
}
return s;
}
const SMALL = 500;
const LARGE = 2000; // 4× — O(n) ⇒ ratio ~1, O(n²) ⇒ ratio ~4
const REPS = 15; // median over more reps → stabler time signal at small absolute ms
const FP_SIZE = 15; // fixed size for the behavior fingerprint
const NO_CAP = 0; // measure the algorithm, not the production safety cap
// ---- timing ----
function median(xs) {
const s = [...xs].sort((a, b) => a - b);
const m = Math.floor(s.length / 2);
return s.length % 2 ? s[m] : (s[m - 1] + s[m]) / 2;
}
function measureCollect(tk, src, file, reps) {
const root = tk.parse(src).rootNode; // parse ONCE; reuse across reps
collectFunctionCfgs(root, tk.visitor, `warmup-${file}`, NO_CAP); // warm JIT (uncounted)
const samples = [];
let out;
for (let i = 0; i < reps; i++) {
const start = process.hrtime.bigint();
out = collectFunctionCfgs(root, tk.visitor, file, NO_CAP);
samples.push(Number(process.hrtime.bigint() - start) / 1e6);
}
return {
ms: median(samples),
cfgs: out.cfgs,
blockCount: out.cfgs.reduce((a, c) => a + c.blocks.length, 0),
// DISK growth: utf8 byte size of the serialized cfgSideChannel — exactly
// what a --pdg run writes onto every ParsedFile shard in the durable store
// + parse cache (the field is plain JSON, so this is the on-disk delta).
// Should scale linearly with source covered; a super-linear ratio means the
// CFG duplicates text and bloats warm-cache shards at scale.
diskBytes: Buffer.byteLength(JSON.stringify(out.cfgs), 'utf8'),
};
}
// ---- reaching-defs solve cost (#2082 M2) ----
// Times computeReachingDefs over a scenario's collected CFGs (the exact work
// the scope-resolution emit loop adds per file on a --pdg run). `maxFacts`
// mirrors the per-scenario production posture: 0 (unlimited) measures the
// algorithm; the production default exercises the boundedness contract.
// When `blockVisitsMul` > 0 each call also passes the PRODUCTION per-function
// maxBlockVisits budget (blocks × mul). On the deep-nest scenario this is how
// "the ceiling stops firing" (#2201) is measured: the dense worklist would
// truncate to an empty result under this budget, whereas the production SSA
// solver computes the full facts — so a nonzero `facts` under the budget is the
// gate (see facts_large_min in baselines.json).
function measureReachingDefs(cfgs, reps, maxFacts, blockVisitsMul = 0) {
const limitsFor = (c) =>
blockVisitsMul > 0
? { maxFacts, maxBlockVisits: c.blocks.length * blockVisitsMul }
: { maxFacts };
for (const c of cfgs) computeReachingDefs(c, limitsFor(c)); // warm JIT
const samples = [];
let facts = 0;
let allComputed = true;
for (let i = 0; i < reps; i++) {
const start = process.hrtime.bigint();
facts = 0;
for (const c of cfgs) {
const r = computeReachingDefs(c, limitsFor(c));
facts += r.facts.length;
if (r.status !== 'computed') allComputed = false;
}
samples.push(Number(process.hrtime.bigint() - start) / 1e6);
}
return { ms: median(samples), facts, allComputed };
}
// ---- taint pass cost (#2083 M3 U7) ----
// Times the EXACT per-function sequence the in-phase emit driver runs on a
// --pdg run for a taint-modeled language: match sites → zero-match fast path
// → computeReachingDefs → computeTaintFlows. `cap` is the scenario's
// maxFindingsPerFunction (deliberately small so the cap BINDS on the dense
// generator). Also sums the encoded TAINTED `reason` bytes for the kept
// findings — the persisted-taint disk posture (R10).
function measureTaint(cfgs, reps, cap, taintModel) {
const importIndex = buildTaintImportIndex([]); // bench callees are globals
const pass = () => {
const refine = createMemoizedRefinement();
let analyzed = 0;
let kept = 0;
let dropped = 0;
let reasonBytes = 0;
for (const c of cfgs) {
const matches = matchFunctionSites(c, taintModel, importIndex);
if (!matches.hasSource || !matches.hasSink) continue;
const du = computeReachingDefs(c, {
maxFacts: DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_REACHING_DEF_FACTS_PER_FUNCTION,
});
const flows = computeTaintFlows(
c,
du,
matches,
{
maxFindingsPerFunction: cap,
maxHops: DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_TAINT_HOPS,
},
refine(c),
);
if (flows.status !== 'computed') continue;
analyzed++;
kept += flows.findings.length;
dropped += flows.droppedFindings;
for (const f of flows.findings) {
// All structural chars + identifier names are single-byte ASCII, so
// string length IS the byte length (path-codec discipline).
reasonBytes += encodeTaintPath(
f.hops.map((h) => ({ name: h.name, line: h.point.line, viaCall: h.viaCall })),
{ truncated: f.hopsTruncated === true, kind: f.sinkKind },
).reason.length;
}
}
return { analyzed, kept, dropped, reasonBytes };
};
pass(); // warm JIT (uncounted)
const samples = [];
let out;
for (let i = 0; i < reps; i++) {
const start = process.hrtime.bigint();
out = pass();
samples.push(Number(process.hrtime.bigint() - start) / 1e6);
}
return { ms: median(samples), ...out };
}
// Use the production policy and matching/solver path; only the fixture's global
// spelling replaces import resolution, which is covered by integration tests.
const GUARD_MODEL = {
...TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL,
sinks: TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL.sinks
.filter((entry) => entry.name === 'execSync')
.map((entry) => ({ ...entry, module: undefined, global: true })),
};
function measureGuards(cfgs, reps) {
const imports = buildTaintImportIndex([]);
const pass = (input) => {
const refine = createMemoizedRefinement();
let visits = 0,
fallbacks = 0,
findings = 0,
forwardEffects = 0;
for (const cfg of input) {
const refinement = refine(cfg);
visits += refinement.guards.visits;
if (refinement.guards.status === 'fallback') fallbacks++;
const matches = matchFunctionSites(cfg, GUARD_MODEL, imports);
const du = computeReachingDefs(cfg);
if (matches.hasSource && matches.hasSink)
findings += computeTaintFlows(cfg, du, matches, undefined, refinement).findings.length;
forwardEffects += harvestFunctionSummary(
cfg,
du,
matches,
refinement,
).facts.paramToCallArg.filter(
(edge) => edge.calleeName === 'forward' && edge.valueEffect?.kind === 'restrict',
).length;
}
return { visits, fallbacks, findings, forwardEffects };
};
pass(cfgs);
const samples = [];
let result;
for (let i = 0; i < reps; i++) {
const start = process.hrtime.bigint();
result = pass(cfgs);
samples.push(Number(process.hrtime.bigint() - start) / 1e6);
}
const replay = JSON.parse(JSON.stringify(cfgs));
const start = process.hrtime.bigint();
const replayResult = pass(replay);
return {
ms: median(samples),
...result,
replayMs: Number(process.hrtime.bigint() - start) / 1e6,
replayEqual: JSON.stringify(result) === JSON.stringify(replayResult),
};
}
// ---- memory growth: retained heap of the cfgSideChannel payload ----
// Needs `node --expose-gc` to force collection for a clean delta; without it the
// heap metric is reported as null and its --check gate is skipped (so a local
// run without the flag still works).
const GC = typeof global.gc === 'function' ? () => (global.gc(), global.gc()) : null;
function retainedHeapBytes(tk, src, file) {
if (!GC) return null;
// Retained-size-by-RELEASE: measure the heap with the CFGs held, drop them,
// GC, measure again. The drop isolates exactly the JS heap the cfgSideChannel
// payload retains (the extra RAM a --pdg run carries per file until the shard
// is flushed) — robust to pre-existing garbage, which is constant across both
// measurements. The parse tree is a temporary (its native memory isn't on the
// JS heap); block text strings are fresh copies, so they count here.
let cfgs = collectFunctionCfgs(tk.parse(src).rootNode, tk.visitor, file, NO_CAP).cfgs;
GC();
const withCfgs = process.memoryUsage().heapUsed;
if (cfgs.length < 0) throw new Error('unreachable'); // keep cfgs live past withCfgs
cfgs = null;
GC();
const withoutCfgs = process.memoryUsage().heapUsed;
return Math.max(0, withCfgs - withoutCfgs);
}
// ---- correctness fingerprint (order-independent over blocks + edges) ----
function canonicalizeCfg(cfg) {
const blocks = cfg.blocks
.map(
(b) =>
`B|${b.index}|${b.startLine}-${b.endLine}|${b.kind}|${b.text}|` +
// #2082 M2: statement facts join the canon so harvest drift (lost
// defs/uses, changed binding resolution) trips the fingerprint gate.
JSON.stringify(b.statements ?? null),
)
.sort();
const edges = cfg.edges.map((e) => `E|${e.from}->${e.to}|${e.kind}`).sort();
const bindings = JSON.stringify(cfg.bindings ?? null);
return `${cfg.functionStartLine}:${cfg.functionStartColumn}\n${bindings}\n${blocks.join('\n')}\n${edges.join('\n')}`;
}
function fingerprint(tk, scenario) {
const out = collectFunctionCfgs(
tk.parse(scenario.gen(FP_SIZE)).rootNode,
tk.visitor,
'fp',
NO_CAP,
);
const canon = out.cfgs.map(canonicalizeCfg).sort().join('\n====\n');
return {
fingerprint: crypto.createHash('sha256').update(canon).digest('hex'),
fp_cfgs: out.cfgs.length,
fp_blocks: out.cfgs.reduce((a, c) => a + c.blocks.length, 0),
fp_edges: out.cfgs.reduce((a, c) => a + c.edges.length, 0),
};
}
function measureScenario(scenario) {
// Resolve the scenario's language toolkit ONCE (default 'ts' keeps every
// pre-existing TS scenario on the exact same grammar+visitor+model path it
// used before the U1 parameterization → byte-identical baselines).
const tk = langToolkit(scenario.lang ?? 'ts');
// Per-scenario sizes (straight-line needs larger N to separate a concat
// quadratic from noise — see its comment); the rest default to the globals.
const nSmall = scenario.small ?? SMALL;
const nLarge = scenario.large ?? LARGE;
const small = measureCollect(tk, scenario.gen(nSmall), `${scenario.name}.src`, REPS);
const large = measureCollect(tk, scenario.gen(nLarge), `${scenario.name}.src`, REPS);
const sizeRatio = nLarge / nSmall;
const scalingRatio = small.ms > 0 ? large.ms / small.ms / sizeRatio : 0;
const diskRatio = small.diskBytes > 0 ? large.diskBytes / small.diskBytes / sizeRatio : 0;
// Memory growth (only when --expose-gc gave us a forced GC).
const heapSmall = retainedHeapBytes(tk, scenario.gen(nSmall), `${scenario.name}.src`);
const heapLarge = retainedHeapBytes(tk, scenario.gen(nLarge), `${scenario.name}.src`);
const heapRatio =
heapSmall !== null && heapLarge !== null && heapSmall > 0
? heapLarge / heapSmall / sizeRatio
: null;
// #2082 M2: reaching-defs solve cost over the same CFGs. #2201: scenarios
// marked `rdProductionBudget` also pass the per-function blocks×64 ceiling, to
// prove the production SSA solver still COMPUTES where the dense worklist would
// truncate (the deep-nest ceiling-stops-firing acceptance).
const rdMaxFacts = scenario.rdMaxFacts ?? 0;
const rdBudgetMul = scenario.rdProductionBudget ? DEFAULT_PDG_MAX_REACHING_DEF_BLOCK_REVISITS : 0;
const rdSmall = measureReachingDefs(small.cfgs, REPS, rdMaxFacts, rdBudgetMul);
const rdLarge = measureReachingDefs(large.cfgs, REPS, rdMaxFacts, rdBudgetMul);
// Clamp the denominator: a 0.000ms small-N median would otherwise yield
// ratio 0 and the gate would self-disable exactly when the solver is fast.
const rdRatio = rdLarge.ms / Math.max(rdSmall.ms, 0.001) / sizeRatio;
// #2083 M3 U7: taint pass cost + boundedness on taint-bearing scenarios. The
// taint model is the scenario's language model (TS_JS_TAINT_MODEL for the TS
// taint-dense scenario; a taint scenario requires a model-bearing language).
let taintMetrics = {};
if (scenario.taint !== undefined) {
if (!tk.taintModel)
throw new Error(
`bench: scenario '${scenario.name}' has a taint config but lang '${scenario.lang ?? 'ts'}' has no taint model`,
);
const cap = scenario.taint.cap;
const tSmall = measureTaint(small.cfgs, REPS, cap, tk.taintModel);
const tLarge = measureTaint(large.cfgs, REPS, cap, tk.taintModel);
const tRatio = tLarge.ms / Math.max(tSmall.ms, 0.001) / sizeRatio;
// Zero-match control: identical CFG shape, no model hits — measures the
// match-gate overhead unmatched functions pay on a real --pdg repo.
const zeroCfgs = collectFunctionCfgs(
tk.parse(scenario.genZero(nLarge)).rootNode,
tk.visitor,
`${scenario.name}-zero.src`,
NO_CAP,
).cfgs;
const tZero = measureTaint(zeroCfgs, REPS, cap, tk.taintModel);
taintMetrics = {
taint_ms_small: Number(tSmall.ms.toFixed(3)),
taint_ms_large: Number(tLarge.ms.toFixed(3)),
taint_scaling_ratio: Number(tRatio.toFixed(3)),
// Boundedness: kept findings PER ANALYZED FUNCTION (total findings grow
// linearly with N by design — the per-function pin is the cap gate).
taint_findings_per_fn_small: tSmall.analyzed > 0 ? tSmall.kept / tSmall.analyzed : 0,
taint_findings_per_fn_large: tLarge.analyzed > 0 ? tLarge.kept / tLarge.analyzed : 0,
taint_dropped_large: tLarge.dropped,
taint_reason_bytes_large: tLarge.reasonBytes,
taint_zero_ms_large: Number(tZero.ms.toFixed(3)),
taint_zero_findings: tZero.kept + tZero.dropped,
taint_zero_match_ratio: Number((tZero.ms / Math.max(tLarge.ms, 0.001)).toFixed(3)),
};
}
let guardMetrics = {};
if (scenario.guard) {
const guarded = measureGuards(large.cfgs, REPS);
guardMetrics = {
guard_ms_large: Number(guarded.ms.toFixed(3)),
guard_visits: guarded.visits,
guard_fallbacks: guarded.fallbacks,
guard_findings: guarded.findings,
guard_forward_effects: guarded.forwardEffects,
guard_replay_ms: Number(guarded.replayMs.toFixed(3)),
guard_replay_equal: guarded.replayEqual,
guard_functions: large.cfgs.length,
};
if (
guarded.findings !== large.cfgs.length * scenario.guard.findingsPerFunction ||
!guarded.replayEqual ||
(scenario.guard.fallback ? guarded.fallbacks !== large.cfgs.length : guarded.visits === 0) ||
(scenario.guard.forwarding && guarded.forwardEffects < large.cfgs.length) ||
guarded.visits > large.cfgs.length * 50_000
) {
throw new Error(
`${scenario.name}: refinement correctness/budget/replay gate failed: ${JSON.stringify(guarded)}`,
);
}
}
return {
...guardMetrics,
...taintMetrics,
scenario: scenario.name,
elapsed_ms_small: Number(small.ms.toFixed(3)),
elapsed_ms_large: Number(large.ms.toFixed(3)),
scaling_ratio: Number(scalingRatio.toFixed(3)),
disk_bytes_small: small.diskBytes,
disk_bytes_large: large.diskBytes,
disk_bytes_ratio: Number(diskRatio.toFixed(3)),
heap_bytes_small: heapSmall,
heap_bytes_large: heapLarge,
heap_ratio: heapRatio === null ? null : Number(heapRatio.toFixed(3)),
blocks_small: small.blockCount,
blocks_large: large.blockCount,
rd_ms_small: Number(rdSmall.ms.toFixed(3)),
rd_ms_large: Number(rdLarge.ms.toFixed(3)),
rd_scaling_ratio: Number(rdRatio.toFixed(3)),
facts_small: rdSmall.facts,
facts_large: rdLarge.facts,
rd_all_computed: rdLarge.allComputed,
...fingerprint(tk, scenario),
};
}
// ---- run ----
const CHECK = process.argv.includes('--check');
// The retained-heap budget is a primary regression detector, but it can only be
// measured with a forced GC. Rather than let `--check` silently PASS with the
// heap gate skipped (a green no-op if someone drops --expose-gc), fail loudly.
if (CHECK && !GC) {
process.stderr.write(
'[cfg --check] FAIL: retained-heap gate requires --expose-gc. ' +
'Run: node --expose-gc --import tsx bench/cfg/measure.mjs --check\n',
);
process.exit(1);
}
const results = SCENARIOS.map(measureScenario);
if (!CHECK) {
for (const r of results) process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify(r) + '\n');
} else {
const baselines = JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(BASELINE_PATH, 'utf8'));
const failures = [];
for (const r of results) {
const base = baselines[r.scenario];
if (base === undefined) {
failures.push(`${r.scenario}: no baseline recorded`);
continue;
}
if (r.fingerprint !== base.fingerprint) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: CFG fingerprint drift (got ${r.fingerprint}, expected ${base.fingerprint})`,
);
}
if (r.scaling_ratio >= base.scaling_budget) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: scaling ratio ${r.scaling_ratio} >= budget ${base.scaling_budget} ` +
`(${SMALL}->${LARGE} stmts/fns, ms ${r.elapsed_ms_small}->${r.elapsed_ms_large})`,
);
}
if (base.disk_bytes_budget !== undefined && r.disk_bytes_ratio >= base.disk_bytes_budget) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: cfgSideChannel disk-bytes ratio ${r.disk_bytes_ratio} >= budget ` +
`${base.disk_bytes_budget} (bytes ${r.disk_bytes_small}->${r.disk_bytes_large})`,
);
}
// #2082 M2 gates — rd solve-time scaling, fact-count boundedness, and an
// ABSOLUTE side-channel size ceiling (a ratio gate is blind to a
// constant-factor encoding bloat like named records vs indexed facts).
if (base.rd_scaling_budget !== undefined && r.rd_scaling_ratio >= base.rd_scaling_budget) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: reaching-defs scaling ratio ${r.rd_scaling_ratio} >= budget ` +
`${base.rd_scaling_budget} (ms ${r.rd_ms_small}->${r.rd_ms_large})`,
);
}
if (base.facts_large_max !== undefined && r.facts_large > base.facts_large_max) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: fact materialization ${r.facts_large} > bound ${base.facts_large_max} ` +
`(the maxFacts early-stop is the boundedness contract)`,
);
}
// #2201 deep-nest: under the PRODUCTION blocks×64 budget the SSA solver must
// still COMPUTE full facts (a nonzero floor) where the dense worklist would
// truncate to empty — "the ceiling stops firing".
if (base.facts_large_min !== undefined && r.facts_large < base.facts_large_min) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: only ${r.facts_large} facts < floor ${base.facts_large_min} under the ` +
`production block-visit budget — the ceiling fired (SSA should not truncate here)` +
(r.rd_all_computed ? '' : ` [status != computed]`),
);
}
// Independent of the fact-count floor: under the production budget every
// function in a facts_large_min scenario must report status 'computed'. This
// catches a partial-truncation regression that still clears the count floor.
if (base.facts_large_min !== undefined && r.rd_all_computed === false) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: a function did not reach status 'computed' under the production ` +
`block-visit budget — the SSA solver truncated where it must compute`,
);
}
if (base.disk_bytes_large_max !== undefined && r.disk_bytes_large > base.disk_bytes_large_max) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: cfgSideChannel absolute size ${r.disk_bytes_large} > ceiling ` +
`${base.disk_bytes_large_max} bytes (constant-factor encoding bloat)`,
);
}
// #2083 M3 U7 gates — taint boundedness (per-function findings pinned at
// the cap as N grows), an ABSOLUTE ceiling on persisted TAINTED reason
// bytes, taint solve-time scaling, and the zero-match fast path staying
// ~free relative to the match-dense pass.
if (base.taint_findings_per_fn_pin !== undefined) {
for (const side of ['small', 'large']) {
const perFn = r[`taint_findings_per_fn_${side}`];
if (perFn !== base.taint_findings_per_fn_pin) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: taint findings/function (${side}) ${perFn} != pin ` +
`${base.taint_findings_per_fn_pin} (cap must BIND exactly: above = cap lost, ` +
`below = detection regressed)`,
);
}
}
if (r.taint_zero_findings !== 0) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: zero-match control produced ${r.taint_zero_findings} findings ` +
`(the control must not match the model — generator drift)`,
);
}
}
if (
base.taint_reason_bytes_large_max !== undefined &&
r.taint_reason_bytes_large > base.taint_reason_bytes_large_max
) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: persisted TAINTED reason bytes ${r.taint_reason_bytes_large} > ceiling ` +
`${base.taint_reason_bytes_large_max} (hop-encoding bloat or cap loss)`,
);
}
if (
base.taint_scaling_budget !== undefined &&
r.taint_scaling_ratio >= base.taint_scaling_budget
) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: taint scaling ratio ${r.taint_scaling_ratio} >= budget ` +
`${base.taint_scaling_budget} (ms ${r.taint_ms_small}->${r.taint_ms_large})`,
);
}
if (
base.taint_zero_match_budget !== undefined &&
r.taint_zero_match_ratio >= base.taint_zero_match_budget
) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: zero-match taint time is ${r.taint_zero_match_ratio} of the match-dense ` +
`pass, >= budget ${base.taint_zero_match_budget} (the match gate must keep unmatched ` +
`functions ~free — no solver call)`,
);
}
// Heap gate only when measured (--expose-gc present) AND a budget exists.
if (
base.heap_budget !== undefined &&
r.heap_ratio !== null &&
r.heap_ratio >= base.heap_budget
) {
failures.push(
`${r.scenario}: retained-heap ratio ${r.heap_ratio} >= budget ${base.heap_budget} ` +
`(heap ${r.heap_bytes_small}->${r.heap_bytes_large})`,
);
}
process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify(r) + '\n');
}
if (failures.length > 0) {
for (const f of failures) process.stderr.write(`[cfg --check] FAIL: ${f}\n`);
process.exit(1);
}
process.stderr.write(`[cfg --check] PASS (${results.length} scenarios)\n`);
}