Commit graph

4 commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
azizur100389
4f16bd8023
fix(impact): report scope extraction omissions (#3071)
* fix(impact): surface scope extraction omissions

* fix(impact): preserve complete index fixtures

* fix(impact): preserve scope completeness evidence

* test(analyze): model successful scope extraction in harnesses

---------

Co-authored-by: Gergő Magyar <gergomagyar@icloud.com>
2026-08-29 08:38:20 +01:00
Gergő Magyar
5f4964b4e6
fix: resolve imported/composed FastAPI route path constants (#2391) (#2393)
Some checks are pending
CodeQL / Analyze (javascript-typescript) (push) Waiting to run
CodeQL / Analyze (python) (push) Waiting to run
Gitleaks / gitleaks (push) Waiting to run
Publish / Classify release event (push) Waiting to run
Publish / RC guard (marker + release-PR skip) (push) Blocked by required conditions
Publish / ci (push) Blocked by required conditions
Publish / Publish to npm (push) Blocked by required conditions
Publish / Build & Push RC Docker images (push) Blocked by required conditions
Scorecard / Scorecard analysis (push) Waiting to run
Trivy Image Scan / Trivy (gitnexus-cli) (push) Waiting to run
Trivy Image Scan / Trivy (gitnexus-web) (push) Waiting to run
* feat(routes): add pure Python string-constant resolver (#2391 U1)

* feat(routes): extract Python module constants from tree (#2391 U2)

* feat(routes): capture non-literal FastAPI decorator args + per-file constants, bump parse-cache schema (#2391 U3)

* feat(routes): resolve composed decorator route constants in parse-impl + skip floor (#2391 U4)

* feat(routes): resolve composed FastAPI route constants in group HTTP-contract layer (#2391 U5)

* test(routes): multi-hop, ingestion↔group parity, and warm-cache regression locks (#2391 U6)

* docs(routes): mark the language-agnostic seam for cross-language const resolution (#2391)

* refactor(routes): extract language-agnostic constant-fold core; Python becomes a binding (#2391)

The fold, cycle guard, and depth cap now live in constant-resolver.ts and take a
pluggable ImportResolver. python-const-resolver.ts supplies the Python import
semantics + tree extractor and re-exports the same surface, so no call site
changes. A Spring/Kotlin/C# binding can now reuse the core with its own resolver
(proven by constant-resolver.test.ts driving it with a Java-style resolver).

* fix(routes): treat the constant-fold cycle guard as a recursion stack (#2391)

The `visited` set in `foldName` was added-to but never removed on unwind, so a
constant referenced more than once in a single fold — `A + A`, a reused
separator (`SLASH + PATH + SLASH`), or a diamond `X = P + Q` where P and Q share
a base — tripped the cycle guard on its second occurrence and the whole route
was silently dropped by the skip floor. Pop the guard in `finally` so it tracks
the ACTIVE resolution stack, not every name ever seen: a true cycle (a name
still on the stack) is still caught, but a name that already resolved and popped
folds again. Re-computation stays bounded by MAX_RESOLVE_DEPTH, so no blowup is
reintroduced.

Locked in constant-resolver.test.ts (A+A, reused separator, shared-base
diamond); the pre-existing real-cycle and depth-cap cases still return null.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): make module-constant binding writes mutually exclusive (#2391)

`extractPythonModuleConstants` kept `literals`, `exprs`, and `imports` as three
independent maps: `setName` cleared literals+exprs but never `imports`, and an
import never cleared a prior literal/expr. Since `foldName` checks
literals > exprs > imports regardless of source order, a name that was both
imported and locally (re)assigned kept both bindings and the wrong one won —
`from .c import ROUTE; ROUTE = os.getenv(...)` resolved the STALE import instead
of dropping, a confidently wrong route path (the exact skip-floor invariant
this feature is meant to uphold).

Treat the three maps as one logical namespace: any write to one clears the
other two for that name (via `imports.delete` in `setName` and a `bindImport`
helper), so last-binding-in-source-order wins, matching Python. An import both
imported and dynamically rebound now drops. Folding `+=`/`+` onto an imported
base remains deferred (it drops safely, never a stale value).

Locked in python-const-resolver.test.ts: dynamic-rebind drops, literal-shadows-
import, import-shadows-literal, and `+=`-on-import drops.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): widen the group cost-gate to catch literal-leading concats (#2391)

`NONLITERAL_ROUTE_DECORATOR_RE` required the first decorator argument to START
with an identifier, so a string-literal-leading concat like
`@router.get("/api" + SUFFIX)` never tripped `hasComposedRoute`. When such a
route was the ONLY composed shape in a repo, the group layer left `constantsByFile`
empty and dropped the route, while the ingestion side (which has no gate)
resolved `/api/users` and emitted a Route node — an R4 provider/graph parity break.

Widen the gate to also fire on a string-literal-leading `+`-concat, detected by a
`+` before the closing paren on the decorator line. Gating on the `+` (not merely
a leading quote) keeps a plain literal route `@router.get("/x")` OFF the gate, so a
literal-only repo still pays no parse pass.

Locked in fastapi-composed-provider.test.ts: a sole literal-leading concat now
resolves (parseCalls>0 + provider emitted), plus previously-uncovered
`@app.<verb>(CONST)` EXPR-branch resolution; the literal-only no-parse gate case
still passes.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): correct package-init and over-deep relative import resolution (#2391)

Two edges in `resolvePythonImport`:

- `from . import X` (empty module after the dots) resolved to a sibling
  `<dir>.py` instead of the package `<dir>/__init__.py`. Resolve the bare-package
  case to `__init__.py`.
- An over-deep relative import (more extra dots than the importing file has
  directory levels) silently clamped `dirOf('')` to `''` and could match an
  unrelated root-level `<name>.py` — a wrong file. Guard with `walk > depth →
  null` so an import that escapes above the repo root drops (skip floor).

Both preserve the exact-match / ambiguity→null behavior for ordinary relative and
absolute imports.

Locked in python-const-resolver.test.ts: `from . import` → `__init__.py` (and
null when absent), and an over-deep import returns null even when the clamped
target file exists.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): bound parseConstOperands recursion depth (#2391)

`parseConstOperands` recursed on `binary_operator` children with no depth bound.
A stack overflow is not currently reachable (tree-sitter caps expression nesting
below the JS stack limit, so it throws on a deep `+`-chain before this runs), but
add a depth guard (cap 64, mirroring the fold engine's MAX_RESOLVE_DEPTH) as
defense-in-depth: a pathological chain now floors to null (skip) rather than
relying on tree-sitter's limit. The `depth` parameter defaults to 0, so all
existing callers are unaffected.

Locked in python-const-resolver.test.ts: a 100-term `+` chain yields no binding
(null) instead of throwing; ordinary short chains still fold.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* perf(routes): read each .py once in buildPythonRepoContext (#2391)

The group repo-context builder read every `.py` file from disk twice: once in
the `include_router` cross-file pre-pass and again in the #2391 constant
cost-gate loop — an unconditional 2x read on every Python repo, on every group
extraction. Hoist a single read pass that populates one `pyContents` map (and
computes the composed-route cost gate); both the include_router pre-pass and the
constant-map pass now consume the cached content. Behavior-preserving — a
literal-only repo still does one read and zero parses.

Covered by the existing group unit + integration suites (R4 parity and
include_router prefix joins unchanged).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* docs(routes): tidy constant-resolver docs and declaration order (#2391)

Three no-behavior nits from the PR #2393 review:
- Name `conditional_expression` (`x if c else y`) in the `parseConstOperands`
  jsdoc list of shapes that deferred to null.
- Move `NONLITERAL_ROUTE_DECORATOR_RE` above `buildPythonRepoContext`, which
  references it — it read as a forward reference before (runtime-safe, but
  confusing).
- Correct the integration-test comment that called `/v2/api/v1/widgets/get`
  "ingestion-only garnish": the group side emits it too (asserted separately);
  the four paths in that block are the shared-parity set.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(routes): fold `X += "…"` onto an imported base constant (#2391)

Previously `from .c import BASE; BASE += "/v1"` dropped (the extractor could not
represent "the imported prior value" as an operand without self-referencing X and
tripping the cycle guard). Preserve the imported prior under a synthetic `$imp$N`
key — `$` can never appear in a Python identifier, so it cannot collide with a
real name — and reference it, so the augmented assignment folds to
`<imported BASE>/v1`. Extractor-only: no change to the `Operand` type, the fold
core, or the cache shape, so no SCHEMA_BUMP. An imported base that is itself
unresolvable still drops (skip floor preserved — never a wrong path).

Locked in python-const-resolver.test.ts: single and chained `+=` fold onto an
imported base; an unresolvable base still drops.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* refactor(routes): resolve bare decorator constants via the by-name entry (#2391)

The group `resolveExprArg` hand-built `[{ kind: 'ref', name }]` and called
`resolveOperands` for a bare-constant decorator argument — exactly what the
language-agnostic core's `resolveConstant(file, name, repo)` seam does. Call it
directly for the identifier case. This gives the previously test-only by-name
entry point a real production caller (it is the documented reuse seam for future
JVM/other bindings), drops the synthetic operand construction, and lets the now-
unused `Operand` type import go. Behavior-identical — the `+`-concat path still
parses to an operand list and folds via `resolveOperands`.

Guarded by the existing group provider suite (bare-constant and concat cases).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* perf(routes): parse each .py once in buildPythonRepoContext (#2391)

The repo-context builder ran two parse loops — the include_router prefix pre-pass
and the #2391 constant-map pass — so an include_router file in a composed repo was
tree-sitter-parsed twice. Merge them into a single pass that parses each `.py` at
most once and feeds both extractions from the same tree; a file that needs neither
pass is still not parsed at all (cost gates unchanged). Complements the earlier
single-read-pass change (this is the single-parse counterpart).

Behavior-preserving (prefixes, R4 parity, and cost gates verified by the group +
integration suites). Locked with a parseCalls assertion: a file needing both
passes is parsed once, not twice.

Note: a cross-run (cross-process) constant-map cache — the other deferred perf
idea — remains out of scope; it needs disk persistence + invalidation and would
add hashing/IO cost on the common path, so it fails the minimal-change bar this
single-parse dedup meets.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): bound constant-fold work and output to prevent OOM (#2391)

The `finally`-popped cycle guard (recursion-stack semantics) correctly folds
diamonds/repeated refs, but popping the guard removed the accidental work cap the
old seen-ever set provided: a wide shared-descendant DAG re-folds each child once
per reference, and a self-multiplying concat (`X = A + A; A = B + B; …`) builds a
genuinely exponential string. Reviewers reproduced ~16.8M folds escalating to
`RangeError: Invalid string length` and heap OOM — and neither fold call site is
wrapped in try/catch, so it crashed the whole phase rather than dropping the route.

Two complementary bounds, both flooring to null (skip), never a wrong value:
- a never-popped `memo` in `foldName` caps recomputation at O(nodes) (successes
  only — a null may be transient on a cyclic branch);
- a `MAX_FOLD_LENGTH` (8192) cap in `foldExpr` drops a fold whose output grows
  past any real route path, bounding the string size the depth cap does not.

Corrects the prior "≤ 2^8 folds" comment (output grows multiplicatively, not
additively). Locked with a 64^4-fanout construction that now drops in ~ms instead
of OOMing; diamonds/cycles/depth-cap behavior unchanged.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): snapshot assignment RHS refs at the assignment line (#2391)

`ROUTE = BASE` was stored as a lazy `ref(BASE)`, resolved against BASE's FINAL
binding. So `ROUTE = BASE; BASE += "/v1"` (or `ROUTE = API; API = "/other"`)
resolved ROUTE to the MUTATED value — a confidently wrong path, since Python
assigns by value at the `ROUTE =` line. This was latent for local constants at
the base of this feature and the `+=`-on-import work extended it to imports.

Snapshot each assignment/`+=` RHS reference to a bound name into that name's
current frozen value at the assignment line (`freeze`/`snapshot`): a literal
value, a copy of the current expr (whose refs are already frozen), or an import
preserved under a `$imp$N` alias. Unbound refs (forward references) stay lazy.
A later rebind of the aliased name can no longer change the earlier binding.
`freeze` also unifies the previous `currentOps` + inline import-alias logic.

Locked in python-const-resolver.test.ts: aliased-import-then-`+=`,
aliased-local-then-`+=`, aliased-local-then-rebind all resolve to the pre-mutation
value; normal reference chains still fold.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): fold group identifier args via resolveOperands for parity (#2391)

Resolving a bare-constant decorator arg through `resolveConstant` entered
`foldName` at depth 0, whereas the ingestion side folds `routePathOperands`
through `resolveOperands([{ref}])`, entering at depth 1. At the MAX_RESOLVE_DEPTH
boundary the group tolerated one more hop than ingestion, so a deep alias/re-export
chain resolved in the group provider set but dropped from the graph Route nodes —
an R4 parity break. Restore the operand-list path in the group so both subsystems
share identical fold-entry depth. (`resolveConstant` reverts to the documented
agnostic-core seam.)

Locked in constant-resolver.test.ts: a 4-hop chain that `resolveOperands([ref])`
drops but `resolveConstant` resolves, documenting why the group must use the
operand-list entry.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): match multiline literal-leading concats in the cost gate (#2391)

`NONLITERAL_ROUTE_DECORATOR_RE` used `[^)\n]*` so it only saw a literal-leading
`+`-concat when the `+` was on the same line as the opening quote. A
Black-formatted `@router.get(\n "/api"\n + SUFFIX\n)` therefore failed the gate,
and when it was the only composed route in a repo the group dropped it while
ingestion (which parses the tree, not the raw line) resolved it — an R4 parity
break. Drop the `\n` exclusion: `[^)]*` spans the wrapped argument but stays
bounded by the decorator's own closing paren, so a plain literal route still
never trips the gate.

Locked in fastapi-composed-provider.test.ts with a multiline concat fixture.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(routes): bump SCHEMA_BUMP for changed extractor output + E2E snapshot lock (#2391)

`extractPythonModuleConstants` now emits DIFFERENT `moduleConstants` for the same
source (binding mutual-exclusivity clears stale imports; RHS refs are snapshotted;
`$imp$N` aliases). That output is cached verbatim in the parse cache, so a warm
shard built at the pre-fix version would replay stale — in one case actively
wrong — folded values, and the correctness fixes would silently no-op on upgrade.
Bump SCHEMA_BUMP 11→12 to force re-extraction (same warm-cache-replay class the
original 10→11 bump addressed for the field addition).

Also adds the first end-to-end coverage for the new behavior through the real
ingestion pipeline: app/snapshot.py aliases a constant (`SNAP = API_V1`) then
mutates the source (`API_V1 += "/mutated"`), and the test asserts the Route node
is `/api/v1`, never `/api/v1/mutated` — a case the pure-function unit tests
covered but the pipeline did not.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-07 13:23:05 +01:00
henry201605
d7ff76e6e9
fix(ingestion/routes): resolve Spring interface-inherited routes (#2288) (#2290) 2026-06-25 09:22:20 +01:00
Gergő Magyar
3d30b94c46
fix(parse): survive non-cloneable worker results so large-repo analyze doesn't crash (#2112) (#2135)
* fix(parse): survive non-cloneable worker results so large-repo analyze doesn't crash (#2112)

A parse worker delivers its accumulated result to the main thread via
postMessage, which structured-clones the payload synchronously on the
worker thread and throws a DataCloneError on the first value it can't
serialize. The reporter's case was a node `properties` value pointing at
a native `toString`. The worker re-posted the throw as {type:'error'},
the pool counted it as a worker death, and under
GITNEXUS_WORKER_POOL_SIZE=1 the same graph re-threw on every respawn
until the slot's budget was exhausted and the whole parse phase aborted
-- defeating even the conservative single-worker workaround.

Add a clone-safety net at the worker result boundary. On a clone failure
the worker isolates the offending file, strips the non-cloneable value
from a plain extraction record (keeping the record -- strictly-missing
data, never wrong) or drops a whole ParsedFile so scope-resolution
re-derives it on the main thread with intact edge data, records the
affected paths on the result, warns naming the field + file so the leak
is diagnosable, and re-posts. Healthy runs are byte-identical: the net
runs only after a real DataCloneError, so there is zero overhead on the
fast path. Skipped paths surface via the parsing processor alongside the
skipped-language telemetry. The strip drops the same values the store
path's JSON.stringify already silently removes, so store/no-store runs
converge.

Scope: PR-1 -- failure mode C, the deterministic POOL_SIZE=1 killer. The
timeout/native-abort graceful-degradation cascade (failure modes A & B)
is coupled to downstream-exclusion + a hard worker watchdog and is
tracked as follow-up work.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): fail-closed clone-safety recovery + bound recursion depth (#2135 review)

The clone-safety recovery path could re-arm the #2112 worker-death cascade it
was built to prevent: in postResultCloneSafe the sanitizer call and the re-post
sat outside the try/catch, and containsNonCloneable/stripNonCloneable recursed
with a cycle guard but no depth bound. A throw inside the sanitizer (a RangeError
from a deeply-nested record, reproduced at depth >=3000) escaped to the message
handler's {type:'error'}, which under GITNEXUS_WORKER_POOL_SIZE=1 is the
respawn-budget-exhaustion abort.

Wrap the sanitizer + re-post in their own try/catch so any throw fails closed to
a primitive-only {type:'error'} deliberately, and thread a MAX_CLONE_DEPTH bound
through both scan/strip functions so an over-deep subtree is treated as
non-cloneable (dropped/undefined) instead of overflowing the stack. The
isStructuredCloneable catch-all is left broad on purpose — it bounds
structuredClone's own internal recursion in the non-plain-object probe.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): harden clone-safety against throwing getters and detached buffers (#2135 review)

Two sanitizer-defeat vectors let the re-post throw a DataCloneError again:

- A throwing getter on a record: containsNonCloneable/stripNonCloneable read
  obj[key], so a getter that throws escaped the scan/strip pass. Read defensively
  — a throwing property read is treated as non-cloneable (scan returns true,
  strip drops the property).
- A detached ArrayBuffer/TypedArray: both passed buffers/views through
  unconditionally, but structuredClone rejects a detached one, so the re-post
  threw. Route buffers/views through the authoritative isStructuredCloneable
  probe instead. No byteLength heuristic — a legitimately empty new Uint8Array(0)
  also has byteLength 0 yet clones fine, so a length check would false-positive.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): memoize stripped copies so DAG-aliased records aren't over-dropped (#2135 review)

stripNonCloneable carried a shared `seen` WeakSet and returned the ORIGINAL
(un-stripped) value on revisit. When a non-cloneable was reachable via two paths
(a DAG), the second path spliced the original function-bearing object back into
the output, so the rebuilt element failed the last-resort isStructuredCloneable
guard and the whole record was dropped as "unsalvageable" — contradicting the
"record kept, value stripped" contract.

Replace the WeakSet with a Map<object, stripped-copy>: allocate the empty copy,
memoize it before recursing into children (so cycles return the in-progress
copy), and return the memoized copy on revisit. DAG-aliased subtrees now collapse
to one shared stripped copy and are kept-and-stripped, not dropped. The array
branch moves from .map() to allocate-then-push so its identity can be
pre-inserted. Object Map/Set keys aren't identity-preserved across stripping —
acceptable because parse-result Maps are primitive-keyed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* perf(parse): single-pass clone-safety scan preserving array identity (#2135 review)

makeWorkerResultCloneSafe scanned each dirty array twice — a field-level
whole-array containsNonCloneable probe, then a per-element pass — and always
reassigned the field. Fold into one per-element pass that builds the output
array lazily (copying the clean prefix only once the first dirty element
appears) and reassigns the field only when something changed. A fully-clean
array is now scanned once and keeps its referential identity; the clean prefix
of a dirty array is copied by reference. Behavior is otherwise identical
(failure-path-only code).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* refactor(parse): drop unused generic + pin clone-safe field names to keyof (#2135 review)

makeWorkerResultCloneSafe carried a generic `<T extends Record<string,unknown>>`
that was never load-bearing (it mutates in place and returns {skipped}), and the
call site passed untyped string-literal option sets — so renaming `parsedFiles`
or `skippedPaths` would silently disable the drop-whole / skip protection.

Drop the generic (plain `Record<string,unknown>` param) and type the option sets
at the call site as `Set<keyof ParseWorkerResult>`, so a field rename is now a
compile error. The `as unknown as Record<string,unknown>` widening stays — it's
the standard cast for a no-index-signature interface (TS rejects a single-step
`as`); the function genuinely operates structurally on the result's arrays.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): keep the per-file reason in the clone-safety skip log (#2135 review)

The processor's skipped-file warning logged only the paths, dropping the
per-file reason the worker already attached — losing the distinction between a
recoverable "stripped N value(s)" and a whole-record "dropped" entry. Format each
entry as `path (reason)` so the aggregate line carries the diagnostic detail.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): deterministic findFilePath attribution for ParsedNode (#2135 review)

findFilePath swept all child objects one level deep in Object.keys order, so a
ParsedNode could be attributed to a sibling child's path-like key instead of its
real path at properties.filePath. Check the known `properties` child first, then
fall back to the generic sweep, so node attribution is deterministic.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): zero skippedPaths in the slim cache result (#2135 review)

slimParseWorkerResultsForCache spread the worker result without clearing the
clone-safety skippedPaths telemetry, so a sanitized result persisted its skip
list into the on-disk parse-cache shard. Replay already ignores the field; zero
it (like calls/assignments/parsedFiles) to keep shards lean and the intent
explicit.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(parse): exercise real postResultCloneSafe wiring + tighten RED control (#2135 review)

The integration GREEN worker re-implemented postResultCloneSafe inline, so the
production wiring (the {type:'warning'} post + the skippedPaths append) had no
coverage, and the RED control asserted a bare .rejects.toThrow() that any
failure would satisfy.

Extract postResultCloneSafe into a side-effect-free module (post-result.ts) —
importing it from the parse-worker entry module would construct the parser, post
ready, and attach the real handler — and have the GREEN test worker import and
call the real one. Tighten the RED matcher to the actual abort contract
(/circuit breaker|consecutive failures|respawn budget|could not be cloned/),
which also documents that the raw poison result aborts via the pool's
consecutive-failure circuit breaker under POOL_SIZE=1.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): recover the clone-safety net from any post failure, not only DataCloneError (#2135 review)

The V8 structured-clone research surfaced the net's one real correctness hole:
structuredClone invokes getters, and a getter that THROWS surfaces its own error
(a RangeError, etc.) — NOT a DataCloneError (confirmed against a real
MessageChannel). postResultCloneSafe gated recovery on isDataCloneError, so such
a throw re-threw past the sanitizer and re-armed, under POOL_SIZE=1, the
worker-death cascade the net exists to prevent.

Attempt the sanitize + re-post recovery for ANY first-post failure (the sanitizer
already reads properties defensively, so a throwing getter is dropped), falling
closed to a primitive-only {type:'error'} only if the re-post still fails. Adds
an integration case: a node with a throwing getter is recovered and delivered,
not re-thrown.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(parse): name the exact offending key path in the clone-skip diagnostic (#2135 review)

The clone-safety net's skip reason named only the array field + file ("stripped
1 value from nodes"), not the offending property key — which is precisely why
the original #2112 leak stayed unpinned. Thread a dotted key path through
stripNonCloneable (recording each stripped value's path: properties.toString,
meta.data[3], …) and surface the first few in the reason ("from nodes:
properties.toString"). Now a single log line — or the contract/strict checks —
names the leaking property, so a residual runtime escape can be fixed at source.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(parse): clone contract — a representative ParseWorkerResult is structured-cloneable (#2135 review)

Shape-regression guard: builds a representative ParseWorkerResult (typed as the
real interface) and asserts isStructuredCloneable. Typing it as ParseWorkerResult
makes adding a new boundary field a compile error here until the test is updated,
and the runtime assert catches a field whose type regresses to a non-cloneable
shape — independent of language input.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(parse): strict-mode clone gate (GITNEXUS_STRICT_CLONE) — fail loudly instead of silent sanitize (#2135 review)

The runtime net's silent recovery in production is exactly what let the original
#2112 leak stay unpinned. Add an opt-in strict mode (GITNEXUS_STRICT_CLONE=1,
inherited by workers): on a clone failure, postResultCloneSafe THROWS with the
exact offending key path instead of sanitizing + delivering, so a leak
introduced by a future provider/extractor change fails loudly at its origin
(CI/dev) rather than being quietly stripped. Off in production, where the net
keeps the run alive.

Adds a self-contained integration case (sets the flag, asserts the poison run
rejects with the key path) and skips the synthetic-poison suite under a global
strict run (its value there is running the REAL-extractor integration tests
under strict). Wiring a strict CI lane (GITNEXUS_STRICT_CLONE=1 on a vitest
integration step) is left to the maintainer — it needs a green full-suite
verification and touches the protected workflow.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(server): don't ship pipelineResult across the analyze-worker IPC boundary (#2112)

The forked analyze worker reports completion to the parent over
child_process IPC, which uses Node's DEFAULT 'json' serialization
(api.ts forks with no `serialization:` option). `AnalyzeResult.pipelineResult`
is populated on every successful analysis and carries `pipelineResult.graph`
— the live KnowledgeGraph closure object. Sending the raw result is wrong
three ways: (1) the graph's nodes/relationships getters force-materialize
the entire graph into two arrays and JSON-stringify them on every analyze,
discarded immediately (a multi-hundred-MB no-op on a large repo — the #2112
scenario); (2) the graph's methods are own function properties that JSON
drops silently, so a surviving graph is a husk whose forEachNode() throws far
from the cause; (3) a BigInt/circular value anywhere in the payload makes
process.send throw TypeError synchronously — caught and re-sent as
{type:'error'}, mis-reporting a SUCCESSFUL analysis (DB already written) as a
FAILURE. This is the #2112 failure family on the server path, and unlike the
parse-worker result boundary it has no clone-safety net.

The parent (api.ts) reads only result.repoName; pipelineResult's real
consumers (CLI skill generation, cli/analyze.ts) call runFullAnalysis
in-process and never cross this fork. So project the result down to an
explicit JSON-safe allowlist of scalar fields. Typed as
Omit<AnalyzeResult,'pipelineResult'> so a future non-serializable field added
to AnalyzeResult fails to compile until handled here deliberately.

Found by the #2112 cross-process serialization-boundary audit.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(ingestion): Cloneable<T> + assertCloneable() compile-time clone-boundary guard (#2143)

The runtime clone-safety net is the production backstop; this is its
compile-time complement. The worker result is plain data except a few
`unknown`-typed sinks (a node's `properties` bag, the provider
`extractTemplateConstraints` / `collectCaptureSideChannel` hook returns) —
`unknown` lets a non-serializable value (a function, a leaked tree-sitter
SyntaxNode, …) cross the structured-clone boundary with no compile-time
guard. That is the structural hole #2112 leaked through.

`Cloneable<T>` is a homomorphic recursive mapped type that maps a function or
symbol member to `never`, so a struct carrying one is no longer assignable to
its own `Cloneable<T>`. `assertCloneable(value)` is a runtime identity (zero
cost) whose parameter is `T extends Cloneable<T> ? T : Cloneable<T>`, so a
clone-unsafe argument fails to compile, naming the offending key.

Because it is a homomorphic mapped type it preserves `interface` shapes and
`readonly` modifiers and needs NO index signature on the payload types — this
sidesteps the "closed interface is not assignable to a recursive
index-signature type" wall that blocked the original value-typed-`Cloneable`
attempt (the reason #2143 was deferred from PR #2135). The conditional
parameter type avoids the `T extends Cloneable<T>` circular-constraint error.

Tests: runtime identity contract, plus type-level @ts-expect-error assertions
(enforced by tsconfig.test.json) that a function/symbol member is rejected and
clean interface payloads are accepted. Applied to the real provider hooks in
the next commit.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(ingestion): guard provider clone-boundary hooks with assertCloneable (#2143)

Apply the compile-time guard to the provider hooks that feed the `unknown`-typed
worker-result sinks, so a future non-serializable value in their payloads is a
compile error at the source site rather than a runtime DataCloneError at the
worker post:

- C++  extractTemplateConstraints  (CppConstraintPayload)
- C++  collectCaptureSideChannel    (CppCaptureSideChannel)
- C    collectCaptureSideChannel    (CCaptureSideChannel)
- Kotlin collectCaptureSideChannel  (KotlinCaptureSideChannel)

The C++ template-constraint adapter previously returned `unknown`; it now
returns the concrete `CppConstraintPayload | undefined` and routes its payload
through `assertCloneable`. The side-channel hooks are wrapped at their provider
wiring sites. `assertCloneable` is a runtime identity, so behavior is unchanged
(C static-linkage + C++ constraint suites stay green); the guarantee is the
type-check — src tsc now proves every nested member of those real payload trees
is structured-clone safe.

Test: type-level assertions (enforced by tsconfig.test.json) that each concrete
payload type is `Cloneable<T>`, INDEPENDENT of the provider wiring — so the
regression is caught even if the assertCloneable wrapper is later removed.
Proven non-vacuous (a function-bearing type fails the same assertion).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): scan an array's non-index own properties in the clone sanitizer (#2135 review)

structuredClone serializes an array's NON-index own-enumerable properties (e.g.
`arr.meta = fn`) and throws DataCloneError on a non-cloneable one. The clone
sanitizer's array branches iterated numeric indices only, so such an array was
waved through (containsNonCloneable returned false, makeWorkerResultCloneSafe
left the field unrewritten with skipped:[]) — the re-post then threw, fell
through to the fail-closed {type:'error'}, and re-armed the POOL_SIZE=1 cascade
the net exists to prevent.

Add isArrayIndexKey() and, in BOTH containsNonCloneable and stripNonCloneable
array branches (kept in lockstep), scan/strip the non-index own-enumerable keys
after the index loop. A cloneable non-index prop is carried onto the stripped
copy; a non-cloneable one is stripped and recorded. Not reachable from current
parse output (no extractor attaches non-index array props) — a defense-in-depth
hole closed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): contain a throw inside the clone sanitizer instead of escaping to fail-closed (#2135 review)

findFilePath was documented "never throws" but read element properties
unguarded in its generic sweep — a throwing getter at a non-path key (or a
Proxy with a throwing ownKeys trap) threw out of makeWorkerResultCloneSafe, past
postResultCloneSafe's recovery, to the fail-closed {type:'error'} that under
POOL_SIZE=1 re-arms the cascade the net prevents. Likewise a Proxy with a
throwing getPrototypeOf trap throws inside containsNonCloneable's instanceof
checks.

- findFilePath/pathFromChild now read via safeGet (try/catch) and guard
  Object.keys, honoring the "never throws" contract.
- Each element's sanitize in makeWorkerResultCloneSafe is wrapped: a throw during
  scan/strip drops that one element (recorded as "sanitizer error") rather than
  sinking the whole result — so one pathological element can't fail-close the run.
- Corrected the makeWorkerResultCloneSafe JSDoc ("ONLY after a DataCloneError" →
  after ANY post failure, matching the caller) and documented the deliberate
  failure-path double-traversal (the non-allocating pre-scan is what preserves
  clean-element referential identity).

Tests: a throwing getter on a path-less element is stripped & delivered (not
escaped); a Proxy structural-trap element is dropped, clean siblings survive.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(parse): add a final cloneable postcondition gate to the clone sanitizer (#2135 review)

makeWorkerResultCloneSafe rewrote only ARRAY result fields, so a future
non-array sink (a nested object / Map result field) carrying a non-cloneable
value — or an array field whose own non-index property the element loop didn't
reach — would survive the sanitizer and throw on the re-post. Add a final
`if (!isStructuredCloneable(result))` gate that strips any remaining offending
field in place, making "the returned result is structured-cloneable" a hard
postcondition independent of future ParseWorkerResult shape. Failure-path-only
and a no-op once the array loop already made the result clean (the per-field
probe short-circuits every clean field, so it adds no work or skip entries then).

Tests: a function on a non-array result field is stripped & the result becomes
cloneable; the gate adds no skip entry when the array loop already cleaned up.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(parse): reject an `any`-typed member in the Cloneable<T> compile-time guard (#2135 review)

`Cloneable<any>` previously resolved to `any` (not `never`), so a payload with
an `any`-typed member — the most likely escape hatch, since `unknown` is already
blocked — passed `assertCloneable` with no compile error. Add an `IsAny<T>`
branch (the canonical `0 extends 1 & T` probe) as the FIRST arm so `any` resolves
to `never`, matching how `unknown` is already rejected. It must precede the
primitive arm: `any extends CloneablePrimitive` would otherwise resolve to `any`
and re-admit it.

The IsAny-first arm perturbs inference for a bare `undefined` literal argument
(T infers as `unknown` → never); real consumers pass `X | undefined` unions
(the provider hooks), which are unaffected (src tsc clean), so the runtime
identity test now uses a `string | undefined` value — the realistic shape.

Tests: an `any` member fails `assertCloneable` (@ts-expect-error, enforced by
tsconfig.test.json) and `Cloneable<any>` resolves to `never` at the type level.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(server): type the analyze-worker IPC projection as a Pick allowlist, not Omit (#2135 review)

`AnalyzeResultIpc = Omit<AnalyzeResult,'pipelineResult'>` kept every other field
in the type — including optional ones like `isPrimaryBranch?` — so the type
advertised a field the runtime allowlist never sends, and the doc-comment's
"a future field fails to compile until handled here" only held for REQUIRED
fields. Switch to `Pick<AnalyzeResult, …the six scalar fields…>`: the allowlist
IS the type, so the projection return literal is exhaustive by construction
(omitting a key is a compile error) and a new `AnalyzeResult` field is simply
absent from the wire until deliberately added here. `isPrimaryBranch` is
intentionally excluded (nothing consumes it server-side over this fork; the
parent reads only `repoName`).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* refactor(parse): remove the now-dead isDataCloneError export (#2135 review)

postResultCloneSafe recovers on ANY fast-path post failure and never inspects
the error type (a throwing getter surfaces a RangeError, not a DataCloneError —
gating on the type was the original net-gap bug). isDataCloneError has no
production caller; it was only exercised by its own unit test. Remove the
function and that test block.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* refactor(parse): use the exported SkippedPath type in parsing-processor (#2135 review)

The clone-safety telemetry accumulator inlined `Array<{path,reason}>` — a
structural duplicate of the exported `SkippedPath`. Import and use the canonical
type so a future rename of its fields is a compile error here instead of a silent
structural drift.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* docs(parse): document the cloneable-return contract on the worker-boundary hooks (#2135 review)

extractTemplateConstraints and collectCaptureSideChannel return `unknown` and
feed values across the worker structured-clone boundary, but the hook contracts
didn't state the cloneability requirement — a future language implementing them
without care could leak a non-serializable value. Document that the return MUST
be structured-clone-safe and should be wrapped with assertCloneable, so the
guarantee is a compile error at the source (#2143).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(parse): assert the clone-skip telemetry surfaces in the GREEN integration case (#2135 review)

The GREEN clone-safety integration test asserted only graph content (all files
present), not that the skippedPaths / {type:'warning'} wiring its docstring
claims to cover actually fired. Capture the production logger via _captureLogger
and assert the sanitize telemetry names the offending file (poison.ts) AND the
exact stripped key path (properties.toString) — proving the worker's
skippedPaths append + the parsing-processor warning surfaced end to end.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(server): cover the IPC projection against a real KnowledgeGraph (#2135 review)

The IPC projection tests used a hand-built hostile object. Add a case that puts
a real createKnowledgeGraph (whose nodes/relationships getters would materialize
the whole graph under JSON.stringify) in pipelineResult and asserts the
projection drops it entirely — the serialized payload stays under 300 bytes
(a materialized 50-node graph would be thousands), with the scalar fields intact.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(parse): cover the unsalvageable-drop branch and the skippedPaths merge union (#2135 review)

Two untested clone-safety branches from the tri-review:

- "dropped unsalvageable": a dirty element whose stripped copy is STILL not
  structured-cloneable must be dropped, not delivered (else the re-post throws).
  Add a deterministic test (a non-plain member with a stateful getter that the
  strip-time probe sees clean but that turns into a function on the post-strip
  verification) asserting the element is dropped and the run survives.

- mergeResult skippedPaths union across sub-batches. mergeResult (and its
  appendAll helper) was module-private in the parse-worker ENTRY module, which a
  main-thread test can't import (it runs MessagePort setup). Extract it to a
  side-effect-free result-merge.ts (mirroring post-result.ts) and unit-test the
  union (including the `??=` target-init path), the skippedLanguages sum, and
  array append. parse-worker imports it back; verified the built worker still
  parses + merges via the real-worker integration path.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* style(parse): root-prettier format the clone-safety review-fix files (#2135 review)

Clears the failing `quality / format` CI gate (root prettier, not the
gitnexus-local config). Reformats the pre-existing #2143 wrapping lines in
c-cpp.ts + kotlin.ts plus the clone-safety review-fix files touched in this
PR-update (clone-safety.ts and the new/updated tests). Formatting-only — no
behavior change; tsc, the type-level assertions (tsconfig.test.json), and the
unit + integration suites stay green.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(parse): avoid js/trivial-conditional in the type-level clone assertions (#2135 review)

CodeQL flagged the `expect(a && b && c).toBe(true)` lines in the type-level test
assertions as js/trivial-conditional: after type erasure the operands are
constant `true`, so the `&&` chain always evaluates the same. Replace the `&&`
chain with array equality (`expect([...]).toEqual([true, ...])`) — no
conditional, and the real assertions remain the `const x: …IsNever = true` /
`: IsCloneable<…> = true` annotations (enforced by tsconfig.test.json, which
fail to compile if a guard regresses).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-10 13:47:22 +01:00