2 commits

Author	SHA1	Message	Date
Gergő Magyar	e06c2dd13e	fix(impact): fail closed on id-less targets and follow ??/||/?: callable values (#3354) (#3373) ... * fix(impact): fail closed on id-less targets and follow ??/||/?: callable values (#3354) #3354 reports `impact` returning a byte-identical 1037/CRITICAL/`exact` result for three unrelated targets, with only `target.name` differing. The reporter's `target` had no `id` and no `filePath`, which the traversal path always emits, and a synthetic reproduction of their monorepo (pnpm, Cloudflare worker-configuration.d.ts in five packages, Hono, a Durable Object) resolves every target correctly on main. So the identical result was not reproduced. The repro did surface two real gaps and one hardening point: - `_runImpactBFS` now throws when the target has no node id. Every caller already catches, so impact reports `impactedCount: null, risk: UNKNOWN` instead of a normal-looking blast radius that cannot be about this symbol. - Callable-value flow followed only a single designator on the RHS, so `const sweep = env.__sweep ?? runSweep; await sweep(env)` produced no flow and `scheduled` was missing as a caller of `runSweep`, while the result still claimed `epistemic: exact`. Each branch of `??`, `||`, `or`, and `?:` now flows into the binding (language-neutral: operator and field names, no language checks). Parse cache bumped 104 -> 112 (105-111 are claimed by open PR #3326). - A whitespace-only `target_uid` (strict adapters materialize omitted optional strings) is treated as omitted and falls back to the name. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(mcp): treat a non-string uid as omitted instead of throwing (#3354) Review follow-up on #3373. `query.uid?.trim()` called `.trim()` on a client-supplied value, and the MCP envelope is not type-validated, so `context({uid: 42})` threw a TypeError that `context()` does not catch. Before #3373 the same input ended as a structured not_found. A non-string uid now counts as omitted, which matches how normalizeToolParams already treats a non-string `target_uid`. The impact and trace not-found messages print a trimmed uid only when it is a non-blank string, so a strict adapter sending " " sees the name it searched for instead of `' '`. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): expand ??/?:/ternary branches through a provider hook (#3354) Review follow-up on #3373. The shared value-alternatives rule keys on tree-sitter field names, and several grammars spell the same construct differently, so the expansion never fired for them: - Kotlin `elvis_expression` has no fields. - Swift uses `value`/`if_nil` and `if_true`/`if_false`. - Dart uses `first`/`second`, and its conditional has no `condition` field. - Python `a if c else b` has no fields. The `'?:'` operator entry was dead, since no bundled grammar emits it. Add an optional `valueAlternatives` hook to CallableFlowCaptureOptions, consulted before the shared rule, and implement it in the Kotlin, Swift, Dart, Python and Ruby providers. Shared code still names no language. Ruby's statement-bodied `if`/`unless`/`elsif` also carries `condition`/`consequence`/`alternative`, so the shared ternary rule dug an identifier out of an arbitrary statement (`g = h; 0` flowed `h`) and produced a wrong CALLS edge. The Ruby hook now keeps a multi-statement branch as one opaque source, as before #3373. Tests: new provider fixtures for Python, Kotlin, Swift, Dart and Ruby (including a Ruby negative), and TS chain, parenthesized, callable-left and `&&` negative cases. Captures goldens gain one entry each for the new fixtures. SCHEMA_BUMP stays 112 (same unreleased PR). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): keep long ||/??/?: chains linear in callable-flow capture (#3354) Expanding value-selecting sources into per-branch flows made long chains super-linear and, past a few thousand operands, a stack overflow. A generated `w === "k0" || w === "k1" || ...` keyword table took 6.7 s at 1000 operands and 48 s at 2000, and threw RangeError at 8000. Two causes, both fixed without changing any emitted capture: - valueAlternatives recursed once per operator level and spread the partial results at every level. It is now an explicit stack that writes to one output array. The left-to-right order, the paren unwrapping, and the provider-hook contract (`[node]` means opaque) are unchanged. - Every alternative ran its visibility walks from its own leaf, which can be as deep as the chain is long, all the way to the root. Also, tree-sitter's `parent` re-descends from the root, so each step costs the node's depth. The walks now jump between "anchor" nodes, the only nodes any check can match: region ids and formal owners. The nearest anchor is memoized per node across the file, and parents come from a map recorded by the one DFS the synthesizer already does. After the fix: 0.34 s / 0.23 s / 1.6 s at 1000 / 2000 / 8000 operands. That is within about 1.2x of main without the expansion; what remains is tree-sitter query time. Capture fingerprints are byte-identical before and after the fix for all 16 scope-capture bench languages and for the Python harness. A `typescript-deep-chain` case added to the scope-capture bench guards the scaling: 1.11-1.22 now, 7.5-8.0 before. A unit test pins a 10000-operand chain: it must still yield the seed for a callable operand, the copy for a formal at the deepest leaf, and the invoke. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(kotlin): see through braced if-branches in callable alternatives (#3354) tree-sitter-kotlin wraps a braced branch as `control_structure_body > statements > <expr>`, so for any non-empty block kotlinValueAlternatives saw exactly one named child (`statements`) and pushed the wrapper itself as the branch value. operandSyntax emits nothing for a `statements` node, so `val run = if (c) { ::f } else { ::g }; run()` produced no flow edges, and the "multi-statement block stays opaque" guard could never fire. Descend one level through `statements` and require exactly one non-comment expression there. Empty blocks (`{}` has no named children), multi-statement blocks, and `if` without `else` still return the whole `if` as one opaque source. The doc comment now describes that. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ruby): skip only the multi-statement branch in callable alternatives (#3354) rubyValueAlternatives returned `[node]` (opaque) as soon as one branch held more than one statement. Two things went wrong because of that: - At the top level, `run = if c then g = h; 0 else method(:f) end` dropped the single-statement `else`, so `f` got no flow edge. - In an elsif chain, the outer `if` pushed the `elsif` node as a branch. The shared loop called the hook on it again, got `[elsif]` back, and used the whole elsif subtree as one source. So in `if a then method(:run_a) elsif b then g = h; 0 else method(:run_b) end` the `run_b` edge was lost. The hook now walks the elsif chain itself and skips each multi-statement branch, while every single-statement branch still becomes an alternative. This cannot add a wrong edge: each emitted alternative is a value the conditional really evaluates to, and nothing is taken from the skipped branch. Before, that branch did not contribute a resolvable value either. A whole conditional used as a source becomes a qualified-name seed, which resolves to nothing when it has more than one identifier leaf. With a single identifier leaf, it could even seed the condition variable. When no branch is a single statement, the conditional still stays one opaque source, as before. Ruby captures golden: ruby-callable-alternatives/app.rb goes from 33 to 58 capture groups. 23 of them come from the new fixture functions (checked against the old source). The other 2 are the new branch alternatives, `statement_if -> run_sweep` and `elsif_chain -> run_b`. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): flow the right operand of && / and into callable bindings (#3354) `a && b` / `a and b` yields `a` when it is falsy and `b` otherwise. A falsy value is never a callable, so the right operand is the only one that can be invoked later. The capture left `&&` unexpanded, and the compound source became a qualified seed that resolves to nothing: `const run = x && f; run()` gained no edge to `f` while impact claimed `exact`. Python `x and f or g` reached only `g`. The shared expansion now maps `&&` / `and` to the right branch only. It recurses, so `x and f or g` reaches both `f` and `g`. Where `&&` yields a boolean (Java, C#, Go, Rust, C, C++, PHP, Zig), the destination cannot be invoked, so the flow never meets a call. A before/after CALLS diff over all 83 lang-resolution fixtures that contain `&&` or `and` shows exactly one new edge, logicalAnd -> runAndRight. PHP and Ruby bind low-precedence `and` looser than `=`, so `$g = $x and $y` never reaches this rule. The Python golden digest changes only for the extended python-callable-alternatives fixture. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): keep operator branches of a value-selecting source opaque (#3354) The fan-out sent every branch of `??` / `||` / `or` / `?:` to emitAssignmentFact on its own, including branches that compute a value. `Handlers.fallback === run || fb` then emitted the comparison as a seed whose qualified text sliced to receiver `Handlers`, member `run`, and resolveBoundMemberCandidates minted a CALLS edge to `Handlers.run`. The same happened for `this.state !== run ?? this.fallback`, `this.state + run || this.fallback`, and Python `self.state != run or self.fallback`. Before the fan-out, the whole compound source was one opaque seed. A branch that is a binary operator expression now contributes nothing. The check uses the field vocabulary valueBranches already reads (a `left`/`right` pair, or an `operator`/`operators`/`op` token after the expression start), not grammar type names. Member accesses that field their `.`/`->` as `operator` (Ruby `call`, C/C++ `field_expression`) also field a member name through the list memberParts uses, now shared as memberNameNode, so they stay designators. Unary `&f`/`*fp` lead with their operator and stay designators. Call results were already dropped by emitAssignmentFact, and lambdas and callable references are unchanged. CALLS-edge diff over 87 lang-resolution fixtures (505 -> 501 edges): only the four false edges above were removed, and none were added. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(ingestion): pin the LEFT operand of ?? / or / elvis per provider (#3354) The Python, Kotlin, Swift and Dart "override ?? fn" cases put an unresolvable parameter on the left, so a fan-out that kept only the last operand still passed them. Each fixture now adds a callableLeft case with a real function on the left and a parameter on the right (`run_left or fallback`, `::runLeft ?: fallback`, `runLeft ?? fallback`), and each language asserts `callableLeft → runLeft`. Mutation check: dropping the left branch from the shared `??`/`||`/`or` rule and making the four provider hooks return only their last operand fails all four new tests, while the existing right-operand tests still pass. Capture goldens were regenerated with UPDATE_GOLDEN=1: - python app.py: 35 -> 85 groups. 35 -> 75 is stale drift from 8ad0d8db7, which added the comparison cases without regenerating. 75 -> 85 is the new case: 2 declarations, 2 scopes, the variable, the `run()` reference, and 4 callable-flow captures (seed -> run_left, copy <- fallback, formal, invoke). - swift App.swift: 25 -> 36 groups for the same new case, plus Swift's type-binding for the fallback parameter. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(bench): re-baseline scope-capture fingerprints for #3354 callable alternatives This PR makes a callable chosen by a value-selecting source flow every branch it can yield (??, ||, or, && right operand, ternary, statement if, elvis). It also keeps an operator branch opaque. Both change @callable-flow captures, and the PR adds *-callable-alternatives regression fixtures that these benches glob. To verify, the BASE (merge-base 233ca2849) and HEAD emitters were run over the same HEAD fixture corpus plus the synthetic source. Every added or removed match is an @callable-flow.* match on one of those sources. The pre-existing corpus is byte-identical for all 16 scope-capture languages and for Python. Emitter delta, then corpus growth: - ruby: +5/-0 app.rb (+1 file, +58 groups) - swift: +6/-3 App.swift (+1 file, +36 groups) - dart: +6/-3 app.dart (+1 file, +33 groups) - kotlin: +8/-2 App.kt (+1 file, +71 groups) - typescript: +18/-14 4 files (+288 groups) - python: +11/-7 app.py (+1 file, +85 groups) The removed matches are whole-expression seeds and copies that carried a qualified name of the compound source. They are replaced by one seed or copy per operand. Synthetic scaling counts are unchanged and every scaling ratio stays under budget. Per-language notes are in baselines.json under _rebaselined_3354_callable_alternatives. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * refactor(mcp): share one blank-uid check across impact, trace and symbol lookup (#3354) The "trimmed uid, or omitted when blank/non-string" rule was inlined four times, three of them trimming twice. nonBlankUid() owns it now; behaviour is unchanged. The whitespace and empty target_uid tests collapse into one it.each. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(cfg): correct the Kotlin and Python grammar-field notes (#3354) The Kotlin CFG visitor claimed no control-flow node has fields; a parse of the vendored grammar shows if_expression fields condition/consequence/ alternative (when/for/while/do/try/elvis are fieldless). The Python harvest note listed conditional_expression's children like field names; the node is fieldless and they are positional. Both notes were misleading reviewers of the #3354 value-alternatives hooks. Comment-only. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(ingestion): skip optional-grammar suites in callable-alternatives providers test (#3354) Kotlin, Swift and Dart grammars are optional installs. Guard their describe blocks with isLanguageAvailable, as swift.test.ts and dart.test.ts do, so an install without one of them skips instead of failing. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(ingestion): probe the Dart parser before enabling its providers suite (#3354) isLanguageAvailable only proves the module loaded; tree-sitter-dart can still fail on setLanguage. Probe loadParser/loadLanguage and skip on failure, the same guard dart.test.ts uses. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Gergo Magyar <gergomagyar0@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 5.5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>	2026-09-25 21:43:24 +01:00
Gergő Magyar	ed8ab1c246	fix(scope-resolution): resolve callable reference flows (#2437) (#2522) ... * docs(plans): add provider-hook value-refs plan (#2437) Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(plans): deepen #2437 plan to USES + property-dispatch design Design revised after prior-art research (Kythe ref vs ref/call, Joern METHOD_REF, Feldthaus field-based call graphs, CodeQL impliedReceiverStep): registration sites emit reference-class USES, invocation is recovered by a field-based property-dispatch pass synthesizing CALLS at member-call sites. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(scope-resolution): model provider-hook value references (#2437) Functions referenced as object-literal property values (provider hooks like emitScopeCaptures: emitCppScopeCaptures) previously produced no edge at all, so impact/context reported a false-safe 0 upstream dependents. Two coordinated halves, per prior art (Kythe ref vs ref/call, Joern METHOD_REF, Feldthaus ICSE'13 field-based call graphs, CodeQL impliedReceiverStep): - Registration -> USES: new ReferenceKind 'value-ref'; TS/JS queries capture pair values and shorthand properties (with @reference.property-key); emitted as a reference-class USES edge, reason 'scope-resolution: value-ref'. Resolution is callable-gated so plain values emit nothing. - Dispatch -> CALLS: new shared pass emitPropertyDispatchCalls synthesizes CALLS (reason 'property-dispatch', confidence 0.7, per-key fan-out cap 32 calibrated on this repo's 16-provider hook tables) from member-call sites to every function registered under the same property key. Deviation from plan: the pass owns value-ref resolution entirely via the post-finalize findCallableBindingInScope walker — the shared registries only see pre-finalize local bindings, so imported hooks (the c-cpp.ts case) were unresolvable through lookupForSite; Reference.propertyKey passthrough dropped as unnecessary. SCHEMA_BUMP 13 -> 14: ParsedFile gains value-ref sites + propertyKey. Verified end-to-end: impact(emitCppScopeCaptures, upstream) now reports 8 impacted / HIGH with extractParsedFile (true dispatch caller) at d=1 via property-dispatch and the c-cpp.ts registration via USES. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(scope-resolution): cover value-ref registration and property dispatch (#2437) Integration: same-file/cross-file/aliased/shorthand registrations emit USES; non-callable and destructuring values emit nothing; dispatch sites gain property-dispatch CALLS (incl. JS twins and per-language partitioning); fan-out-capped keys are dropped entirely; factory-call values unchanged. Unit: capture-shape pins for @reference.value-ref + @reference.property-key. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scope-resolution): surface dropped property-dispatch keys in stats (#2437) Review finding: skippedKeys was returned but discarded — a hook table larger than the fan-out cap silently reopened the #2437 gap for those keys. Log dropped keys and fold value-ref USES + dispatch CALLS into referenceEdgesEmitted. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(plans): add callable reference-flow implementation plan * fix(scope-resolution): close property-dispatch review gaps * feat(scope-resolution): add callable flow facts * feat(scope-resolution): resolve callable value flow * feat(scope-resolution): resolve callable references across providers * fix: harden callable reference flow resolution * fix(scope-resolution): preserve callable binding semantics * docs(plans): add pr-2522-review-fixes plan Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(storage): bump INCREMENTAL_SCHEMA_VERSION for callable-value-flow edges Callable-value-flow CALLS/USES edges (#2437) can connect two files whose content did not change, but the incremental write set only covers changed files — a top-up against a pre-v7 index would silently omit the new edges for every unchanged file pair, indefinitely. Force the one-time full re-analyze (review finding 1, #2522). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(storage): sanitize callable-flow sites per-site at load, log drops The load-time validator rejected the WHOLE ParsedFile when one site was malformed or over-bound, with no logging — and C++ legitimately emits empty-string parameterTypes entries ('' = unknown, the ReferenceSite.argumentTypes convention) for cv-only/ERROR-recovered types, so real repos fell into a permanent, silent warm-cache-miss reparse loop through the #1983-sensitive main-thread path (review finding 7, #2522). Now: '' entries are valid in type arrays; a malformed/over-bound site drops only itself (counted, warned once per load); only non-array garbage — evidence the serialization itself is untrustworthy — rejects the file. Deviation from plan §6 wording: validator-side tolerance replaces emit-side clamps — smaller diff, same asymmetry closed at the single chokepoint. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scope-resolution): keep declarations in the union for reassigned callable cells The binding-lookup suppression for fact-constrained cells was wholesale: reassigning a declared function through its own name (greet = other; greet()) deferred the call to the solver, which then refused the lexical lookup that resolves the declaration — an unresolvable RHS yielded zero CALLS for a call that resolved pre-flow (review finding 8, #2522). Suppression now applies only to cells bound by FORMAL facts — its actual purpose (a parameter whose grammar emits no declaration binding must not adopt a same-named outer function). Copy/alias/store/load destinations keep their declaration as an inclusion seed (Andersen-style union). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(scope-resolution): count forfeited deferred sites in the budget-bailout warning On work-budget exhaustion the deferred invoke sites end the run with zero CALLS — free-call fallback and reference emission already skipped them — but the warning said 'ordinary graph emission remains untouched', which is false for exactly those sites. The warning context now carries the unresolved deferred-site count and the comment states the real cost (review finding: budget-bailout honesty, #2522). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * feat(scope-resolution): surface dropped property-dispatch keys in stats and warn payload The over-cap warning carried only a count; the dropped key NAMES were discarded and RunScopeResolutionStats had no field, so the PR-body claim 'includes them in resolver statistics' was unimplemented (review finding, #2522; reviewer ask on the fan-out cap). The warn payload now names up to 20 dropped keys and the stats carry propertyDispatchSkippedKeys. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * refactor(scope-resolution): drop producer-less ownerQualifiedName from formal sites No capture emitter anywhere produces @callable-flow.owner-qualified-name — the solver branch consuming it was unreachable in production, yet the field was typed, parsed, validated, and unit-tested with hand-built input (review finding 16, #2522; YAGNI). Re-add with a real producer if C++ qualified member declarators ever need it. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * refactor(scope-resolution): drop dead callable-flow knobs CallableFlowPassingMode 'callable-object' had no producer and no consumer distinguishing it, and CallableFlowCaptureOptions.extractCallArguments had no language providing it (unlike its live sibling extractCallCallee) — review finding 17, #2522 (YAGNI). The invocation-kind 'callable-object' is a different, live concept and stays. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): bind subscripted callable cells to the container, not the index terminalIdentifier iterates children in reverse, so tbl[i] = handler seeded the INDEX variable's cell (polluting a same-named formal) and tbl[i](7) looked up the callee under i in a different scope — no join, no CALLS edge for the classic function-pointer-array dispatch (review finding 12, #2522). Subscript nodes now recurse into their container field only, in both bindingIdentifier and terminalIdentifier, across the fielded grammars (C/C++/JS/TS/Python/Go/Java). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): make cross-function file-scope callable bindings resolvable Two stacked gaps killed the canonical C callback-registration pattern (fp assigned in init(), called in run()) — the exact #2437 false-safe this PR exists to fix (review finding H1, #2522): 1. isVisibleValueBinding only consulted assignment regions and formals, so a call in a function OTHER than the assigning one emitted no invoke fact. A declared callable-typed binding is now a value binding wherever its declaration is visible (visibleCallableSignature). 2. The C scope query had no @declaration.variable pattern for function- pointer declarators — void (*fp)(int); created no scope-tree binding, so the seed (init) and invoke (run) cells canonicalized to different keys and never joined. Both bare and initialized forms now bind. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(c): detect variadic parameters via the named variadic_parameter node tree-sitter-c materializes '...' as a named variadic_parameter node; the anonymous-token checks never matched, so variadic function-pointer signatures were emitted with a wrong fixed arity and no '...' sentinel (review finding, #2522). C++ is unaffected ('...' stays an anonymous token there); the token checks remain for such grammars. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): emit invoke facts for field-stored callable member calls The C ops-vtable pattern (o->run = handler; o->run(1)) captured the store but never the call — the member path in emitCallFacts bailed for languages without protocol methods, and the value-binding index recorded the member store under the OBJECT's name ('o'), not the member's ('run') (review finding 11/M3, #2522). Member destinations now also record their terminal member name, and a member call whose name-cell has a visible store emits an indirect invoke — gated on the store so plain accessor calls (map.get) stay inert. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(cpp): disambiguate (obj->*ptr)() ERROR recovery by token order tree-sitter-cpp groups the recovered '->*' two ways depending on error-recovery cost (identifier lengths): [identifier, ERROR '->*m'] or [ERROR 'obj->*', identifier]. The recovery assumed the first shape, so the second silently swapped receiver/member and dropped the call site — the committed test passed only by name luck (review finding H2, #2522). The identifier's position relative to '->*' inside the ERROR now decides roles. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(cpp): class members are never file-local in hasFileLocalCallableLinkage The name-keyed file-local set is populated from every static declaration, so an in-class 'static void make();' (external linkage — in-class static means no-instance) and any member sharing a name with a static free function were over-marked, refusing legitimate cross-file declaration/definition joins (review finding 13/M2, #2522). Method and Constructor defs now bypass the name-set, per the hook's own linkage-only contract. Deviation from plan step 13: the regression is a unit-level contract pin rather than an end-to-end join test — C++ merges out-of-line member definitions onto the member node by qualified identity, so the graph shape cannot discriminate the join refusal for members. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(cpp): classify parameter passing mode from the declarator chain only A whole-subtree scan for reference_declarator inverted copy vs alias: void reg(void (*cb)(int& out)) marked the by-value pointer cb as 'reference' because of the NESTED parameter's int&, making the solver back-propagate formal targets into every caller's argument cell — alias semantics for a copy (review finding 14/M5, #2522). The chain walk never descends into nested parameter lists; a reference anywhere ON the chain (int& x, void (*&cb)(int)) still aliases. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ruby): bare identifiers are calls, not callable references Ruby parses a receiver-less zero-arg method call identically to a variable read, so 'action = process' — which CALLS process and stores its return — seeded action with the callable and minted a wrong CALLS edge from any dispatch through it, confirmed end-to-end (review finding 15/HIGH, #2522). New provider knob bareNamesAreCalls: a bare name that is not a provably local value binding and not an explicit reference form (method(:x), lambda/proc) emits no flow fact, on both the assignment and argument paths. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(go): pair multi-value := positionally instead of cross-wiring The shared field fallback took the FIRST LHS identifier and the LAST RHS identifier of Go's expression_list pair, cross-wiring 'a, b := f, g' and synthesizing a garbage comma-joined qualified name — the real relationships were silently dropped (review finding 16, #2522). extractAssignment may now return multiple pairs; Go pairs list entries positionally and emits nothing for a length mismatch (multi-return call RHS). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(java): drop get/test from callableProtocolMethods 'get' and 'test' collide with ubiquitous non-functional-interface APIs (Map/List/Optional/Future.get), so every ordinary container access emitted a spurious callable-object invoke fact — high-volume misleading graph facts with a cross-wiring risk on receiver-name reuse (review finding 17, #2522). Supplier.get/Predicate.test dispatch is deliberately traded away until the check can gate on the receiver's declared type. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(rust): pin the qualified-name no-degrade guard as a hard invariant Rust's scoped_identifier callable-reference capture over-includes unit enum variants and associated constants (Shape::Square seeds as if callable); they stay edge-free only because resolveSeedCandidates refuses to degrade an unresolved qualified name to a simple-name lookup (review finding 18, #2522). Capture-side type filtering would false-negative on tuple-variant constructors, so the guard IS the contract: documented as a hard invariant (Go's mis-shaped multi-value forms also rely on it) and pinned end-to-end. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(php): remove nonexistent optional_parameter node type tree-sitter-php has no 'optional_parameter' — defaults ride on simple_parameter — so the entry was dead weight the #1920 literal gate does not cover for capture-option Sets (review finding 19, #2522). Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(cobol): detect procedure pointers on fixed-format sources Two stacked defects made the feature a no-op on classic sequence-numbered fixed format (review finding 20/H3, #2522): 1. parseDataItemClauses' USAGE alternation knew POINTER but not PROCEDURE-POINTER/FUNCTION-POINTER, so the dataItems filter was dead. 2. The raw-line fallback scanned UNCLEANED text, where the sequence number satisfied the leading digits and the LEVEL NUMBER got captured as the pointer name. It now scans preprocessed lines and requires a letter- initial name (COBOL data names must contain a letter). 161 COBOL preprocessor/copy-expander tests stay green; free-format matrix case unchanged. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(cobol): skip comment lines in SET seed/copy scans A commented-out SET (indicator-column '*'/'/' or free-format '*>') produced a live seed and a false CALLS edge from dead code (review finding 21/M1, #2522). The scan now skips indicator-column comment lines and strips inline '*>' tails before matching. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(architecture): document callable-flow-only mode and skipped-key reporting The Callable-value flow section omitted scopeResolutionEdgeMode: 'callable-flow-only' — a real emit-pipeline branch that suppresses all ordinary emission for standalone providers (review finding 22, #2522) — and predated the skipped-key names/stats surfacing. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * docs(scope-resolution): correct value-ref resolution attribution and stale pdg-gating comments The value-ref contract comment claimed MethodRegistry resolution — the mechanism is the post-finalize findCallableBindingInScope walker owned by emitPropertyDispatchCalls (resolveReferenceSites skips these sites). Three 'only under --pdg' calleeIdSink comments were falsified by the #2437 gating change (callee-id-sink.ts's header was updated; these copies were missed). Review finding 23, #2522. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(ingestion): direct unit coverage for synthesizeCallableFlowCaptures The 1,100-line shared synthesizer had no test naming it — only downstream consumers were covered (review finding 24, #2522). Pins seed/invoke/ formal/argument emission, subscript container binding, store-gated member invokes, produced-value guards, and the bareNamesAreCalls knob over a minimal options object so assertions target the synthesizer's own semantics. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(resolvers): deepen shallow-language coverage; fix Kotlin/Swift reassignment gaps it exposed Adds the COBOL SET x TO y copy-branch scenario and conditional-assignment scenarios for Kotlin, C#, Swift, and Dart (10 languages previously had one generic case each — review finding 25, #2522). The new scenarios exposed two real capture gaps, fixed here: - tree-sitter-kotlin's 'assignment' node is fieldless, so nested reassignments (chosen = ::target inside a block) produced no flow facts; Kotlin's extractAssignment now decomposes it positionally. - tree-sitter-swift fields its assignment as target:/result:, neither in the shared fallback's field lists; both added. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(infra): literal-validation gate for callable-capture option Sets The #1920 gate validates query literals and exported configs but not the module-private *_CALLABLE_CAPTURE_OPTIONS Sets consumed by the shared synthesizer — a typo'd node type silently captures nothing (PHP shipped a dead 'optional_parameter'; review finding 26, #2522). Every <key>NodeTypes Set literal is now validated against its language's grammar; name-carrying sets (callableProtocolMethods, memberPointerOperators) are deliberately outside the contract. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(storage): centralize corrupt-fixture casts into makeStoreEntry The callable-flow store tests scattered 'as unknown as' double-casts per fixture (review finding 27, #2522; standing no-as-any rule). One typed helper now owns the single controlled escape hatch for building malformed serialization-boundary payloads. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(bench): refresh capture fingerprints after review fixes python-scope: the committed baseline (8d5c3699) never matched this branch's code — CI's benchmarks arm was red on the PR head (review finding 2/HIGH, #2522); regenerated (a99e69ab), scaling 1.04 in budget. scope-capture: ruby/cpp/swift/java/kotlin drifted from the review-fix commits (bare-name suppression, passing modes + ->* recovery, assignment fields, protocol narrowing, positional assignment); all 14 languages re-verified PASS with ratios <= 1.18 against the 1.5 budget. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * chore(docs): untrack docs/plans working documents docs/ is gitignored (local working docs); the plan files were force-added past the ignore. Untracked from the index only — they stay on disk. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * test(golden): regenerate captures goldens after callable-flow review fixes The per-language digest guards (csharp/go/php/python/ruby/rust/swift) locked the pre-fix capture output; the review-fix series intentionally changed it — store-gated member invokes, subscript container binding, Ruby bare-name suppression, Swift assignment fields, positional pairing. Regenerated with UPDATE_GOLDEN=1; clean verification run 59/59; all other parity/golden guards (pipeline-graph, spring-route, python parity) pass untouched at 33/33. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(ingestion): prototypes are callees, not callable value cells The cross-function visibility fix indexed EVERY signature-bearing declaration as a value binding — including plain function/method prototypes (void f(int);). Every call to a declared function then became an indirect invoke, and with emitCanonicalInvokeReference (C/C++) minted a free-call reference that resolved through the registry, bypassing the precise passes' two-phase/ambiguity/subobject suppression — eight phantom CALLS edges in the cpp resolver suite on CI. Only declarations whose binding identifier sits under a pointer/ parenthesized declarator (callable-typed variables like void (*fp)(int);) create value cells now. cpp resolver suite 331/331; callable-value-flow + C/C++ suites 181/181 (the cross-function fp regression still passes); cpp fingerprint rebaselined, both bench gates PASS. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>	2026-07-17 17:20:02 +01:00